
El Salvador is a police state, not a model. Since 2022 they've suspended due process, jailed over 90,000 people without warrants, and human rights groups have documented 500+ deaths in custody, many from torture or denied medical care. They also stopped counting people killed by police or found in mass graves as homicides. Gang violence did drop, nobody denies that. But if your crime policy needs suspended rights and uncounted bodies to work, it isn't justice.
"Not the prettiest solution" is an insane way to describe 500+ people dying in custody, many beaten or denied medical care. Even El Salvador's own government admits about 8,000 detainees were innocent. And your own chart shows murders falling hard from 2015, years before the 2022 crackdown. Saying those lives are an acceptable price is exactly the logic of every authoritarian regime. It's easy to call it worth it when it's not your kid in the cell.
I disagree with the policies of Bukele, but if your a Salvadoran (one of the ones not in prison at least) I can see why you’d think the high cost would be worth it due to the astonishingly high level of violence which existed prior to this crackdown. We live in the USA, not El Salvador. We do not have such an astonishingly high rate of violence. Our “tough on crime” policies have been shown to only make crime worse.
In our country, tough on crime policies destabilize the communities they target, and the felony system and lack of rehabilitation means that when people are released, they are likely to commit crimes again. El Salvador doesn’t release people, it’s a police state keeping people in prison without trial. And it was already in a destabilized state due to the civil war.
They fell in 2015 was from government policy, keeping gang leaders isolated while they were in prison, and the gangs slowing down to try and get ahead of any other measures being enacted Still a murder rate of 17.3 before the crackdown, down to 1.3. Like 900 people per year difference