
I mean I think the rhetoric is clear, he’s “downplaying concerns about antisemitism” as if he hasn’t repeatedly clarified that he is someone who will look out for Jews and Arabs alike, he is “mocking” aipac and “blaming” the war for high prices as if aipac bribery shouldn’t be addressed or as if the war isn’t responsible for high prices. It’s just clear that it’s not a neutral fact focused analysis here
What real concerns has he downplayed? All he’s done is lower Israeli/jewish privilege in nyc from its elevated status to that of any other religion or secular interest. And how is focus on aipac outsized? Huge swaths of the population, especially of Mamdanis electorate, care deeply about the fact that their taxes are funding a genocide and aipac is the primary reason that is possible. It is only logical to frequently focus on that
Since when do hard core antisemites like Abdul? Antisemitism is an incredibly intersectional bigotry, chances are if someone hates Jews they’re going to hate Abdul too. Also, obviously, criticizing a lobbying group (i.e. a special interest that has in fact rigged the system, as all lobbying groups have) that represents a foreign state is not bigoted. Costs are in fact rising, especially gas prices, due to the war in Iran that we were dragged into. He’s not wrong.
And honestly dude it is your own rhetoric that is the dangerous type, this equating criticism of Israel with criticism of Jews. Mamdani has been extremely intentional to separate the two, as anyone should. When you cry about criticism of Israel being dangerous to Jews you are just increasing the number of people who associate the two and therefore enter antisemitic territory themselves.
Like imagine if criticism of Saudi Arabia were to be almost always silenced because to speak them alloud would be equated with hatred towards Arabs. Wouldn’t that censorship just make people resentful of Arabs that are now synonymous with Saudi Arabia on the basis of that association?
So you’re saying people should not talk so negatively & truthfully about Israel & AIPAC because it puts Jews in danger? Idk I feel like that’s the issue are media & so many congressmen claiming that that negativity towards AIPAC & Israel is antisemitic & that all Jews love & support those things is what
Well this is why I asked you specifically what he’s done that is actually antisemitic and not just a criticism of Israel. What real concerns has he ignored? And do you not see how your own insistence on equating criticism of Israel with criticism of Jewish people is harmful? I think you’d be hard pressed to find Abdul so carelessly equating the nation and the people as you continue to do
Saying that we went to war with Iran because of Israel & the war with Iran is making things more expensive is not antisemitic. Claiming that AIPAC has an insane amount of favor & influence is not antisemitic. Claiming that AIPAC or Israel is representative of all Jews or all Jews agree & support Israel or AIPAC is indeed antisemitic.
Also it’s the media & our politicians claiming that Jews support Israel & AIPAC along with plenty of Zionst saying this. Which is antisemitic. Telling everyone they can’t or need to end criticism of these things to protect Jews does aid antisemitism & the bs conspiracy that Jews control everything which is as you & I both know not true
I mean I think that’s a silly belief but as you’ve phrased it that’s still not antisemitic, it says nothing about Jewish people as a group just the nation of Israel. I do think the “Jewish people run the world” thing is antisemitic but that’s different from critiques on Israel. And most importantly, Abdul nor any other DSA candidates have ever said that Israel or Jews are in control of our government. All they’ve said is that Israeli lobbyists have way too much power to bribe politicians into
“Not knowing what antisemitism is” is a quite condescending way to talk about a disagreement in understanding. It is true that some bad people in the world are responsible for lots of the harm and that some of them happen to be Jewish. There are some Jewish people overseeing and defending a genocide. It is not antisemitic to acknowledge that there are good and bad Jews just like there are good and bad people of every variety under the sun
I mean I just looked up the definition myself and still fail to see how criticizing Israeli war criminals has anything to do with specific hatred towards to prejudice against Jews, not any different from hating a murder having nothing to do with a particular murderer being a redhead
Yeah I don’t believe Israel is the reason all of Americas issues or problems. But again what I said earlier & what El Sayed has said isn’t antisemitic. Zionist always claim you can criticize Israel yet they call almost every criticism of Israel is declared antisemitic & harmful to Jews by Zionist.
I do appreciate you taking the time to send a real source tho. Couple things about it: 1. It’s from “Jewish post and news” so we know which way the bias leans here just to be fair. 2. It still doesn’t identify anything truly antisemitic about Abdul, only that he is critical of Israel.
The two things it charges him with are aligning himself with “extremists” like Hasan piker (which the author, rather unbelievably, compares to trump aligning himself with David duke) and his blaming domestic issues on lack of funds having partially to do with money being sent abroad to Israel. Which is absurd on both fronts.
Hasan is not an extremist, he got flak for saying that Israeli action itself is one of the primary drivers of antisemitism, which is a pretty defensible idea that has nothing to do with Jew hate. And even this common sense observation Abdul walked away from out of an abundance of caution. And on the budget point it is true that Israeli aid is not the primary cause of domestic shortcomings, however it’s not a lie to say that billions are being spent there that could be spent here. The author of y
Your article downplays the aid to Israel by saying it’s only .5% of the federal budget. The entirety of NASA gets similar amounts of funding. It’s not insane to say that that money shouldn’t be going to genocide, and that it could make some sort of difference if it were spent on helping American people instead
Well aid to Israel isn’t the primary reason that we can’t afford things here, no, but it is a reason. And if we’re looking at spending to cut, it is understandable to just stop funding a genocide as that’s more simple than the nuance involved with better budgeting in the military or something. Elections are built around simple marketable solutions and “take the genocide money and spend it on healthcare” makes a lot of sense
I’m just saying that for all this talk about how he’s an extremist antisemite, all you can find is him calling some stranger a mean name that is also sometimes applied to Jewish people. That’s the only thing even vaguely resembling antisemitism. If that is the standard then basically every public figure could be called an antisemite. You don’t have to dig deep to find hateful quotes from nick fuentes or David duke because they’re actual extremists
i got angry and didn’t say things as clearly as i should have, i apologize. yeah, those things have influence. but overstating their influence to the point where you treat practically every other political actors’ influence as negligible is where it starts to get into harmful territory
What political actors are being treated as negligible? How are the Iran war & AIPAC spending in elections being overstated? Also are you just going to ignore the fact that AES was constantly being asked about Israel & Jews it’s not like he constantly brought that stuff up but like with Zohran it was a common talking point against them forcing them to talk about it more then most people.
Hell he didn’t even play down sexual assault like this article claims. Ironically he did the opposite not that the author cares. He was arguing with a chatter who was claiming that no sexual assault happened & it’s all pro Israel propaganda to claim so. Hasan was telling the person it probably did happen & they’re wrong & that it’s common in things like this but regardless it doesn’t justify a genocide.