Anonymous #5 2w

No, just a supporter of indigenous rights

0

Anonymous #2 2w

I’m not presenting an argument

1

Anonymous #1 2w

No, you can’t actually. If you’re not native, we don’t want you

1

Anonymous #3 2w

Nationalism for all nations ❤️

1

Anonymous OP 2w

“Nation” and “ethnicity” are both artificial constructs which we implement in anthropology and political science but cannot actually define with set boxes in the real world.

6

Anonymous #3 2w

If both are artificial constructs then how can I tell which part of the world someone is from just by looking at them

0

Anonymous OP 2w

Phenotype is something completely separate from both nation and ethnicity lol

1

Anonymous OP 2w

Then you would have an issue with ICE arresting Native Americans for their appearance.

1

Anonymous #3 2w

Indian people look like they’re from India, it’s not that deep

1

Anonymous #5 2w

Yes, because they are more native than anyone else living here

1

Anonymous OP 2w

What if they’re Nepali or Bhutanese or Pakistani or Bangladeshi or Sri Lankan or Maldivian? They could speak a Dravidian or an Indo-Aryan or a Tibeto-Burman language. They could be Hindu or Muslim or Buddhist or Christian or even Jewish. Ethnicity and identity is much more complex than appearance or genetics or arbitrarily drawn borders.

4

Anonymous #3 2w

Sure, but you know roughly where that person is from and nine times out of ten they will have much more in common culturally with people in the surrounding area than people from the other side of the world. If you shuffle people around too much, they will inevitably lose their sense of identity and there’s many problems that follow from that, on an individual and societal level

0