
george_carlin_
Men obsessed with robots and AI are simply jealous of women’s ability to create and host life. Some types of men have always been jealous of that ability. It literally goes all the way back to the creation of the Adam and Eve myth where she came from himThis sounds progressive, but it rests on the most binary idea there is: womanhood = gestation, and manhood = envying it. I'm trans and I'm neither a man nor a woman. Where do I fit in this? Plenty of women can't or won't carry a pregnancy, and plenty of people aren't on either side of your line at all. Reducing us to their reproductive organs isn't feminism. It's biology-as-destiny with a woke coat of paint.
i think it’s important to recognize the inherent capitalistic nature of the current push for artificial intelligence, rather than paint an image of gender binaries upon it. most capitalists are obsessed with artificial intelligence and robots because they wish to create a permanent underclass to replace the current working class; they wish to offset all labor with, frankly, synthetic slaves with explicitly defined constraints.
Look where the comments went right away: "ai chuds have gender dysphoria," "probably just the transgender thing." That's what happens when you treat creativity as a gendered pathology. Being trans becomes a punchline, a diagnosis for whatever you want to mock. Dysphoria isn't an insult, and trans people aren't a symptom of tech culture.
I've been designing systems since I was a kid and making music since I was 7. Photography, 3D, web dev, running my own servers. None of it came from envying anyone's body. It came from curiosity and wanting to build things that didn't exist yet. Creating isn't a resource owned by one sex. People of every gender have been making tools, art and worlds for as long as we've existed. Calling that "jealousy" erases the actual people doing the work.
And even worse, your Adam and Eve point backfires. Genesis Rabbah 8:1 says the first human was created androgynous, then split in two. The origin story literally starts with someone like me. Also, "AI" isn't one thing: running open models at home isn't billionaire cloud AI. Want to critique tech-bro god complexes? Go for it. But you don't get to do it by making trans people the punchline.
it is a manifestation (for most, not all) of the late stages of capitalism fueled by vast technological advances progressing at a rapid rate. personally, this industry should be focused upon researching the actual depth and impact of the technology itself, rather than seeking a goal of labor displacement. I believe that this technology is far better suited to help us explore the potential origins of life, especially with the new advances being made and the new architectures and hardware
starting to come out (as an example: “wetware”, also known as biological computing (highly controversial, but if it’s going to be made (which, imo, should be heavily debated as to whether we even should), then it should be entirely research oriented); neuromorphic hardware (meant to be used with more biologically-inspired neural networks); etc etc.)
this entire field could be not only helping us understand how we came about, as well as further understand the underlying conditions required for life to develop; but it also might already be inadvertently paving the way for the creation of an entirely unique form of life potentially comparable to humans in terms of intellect and sensory depth, and most of us likely wouldn’t be able to recognize the importance of such an event.
You just made the exact same mistake as OP just with a different label. Blaming “capitalism” (it’s really human greed let’s be real) lets the actual people off the hook: the execs, investors and labs making specific choices. And “research only” just hands it back to institutions. Open weights and homebrew labs are mostly people automating their own homes and lives, not producing capital. I didn't start programming to own a slave. I did it to make my life easier. That's the whole point of tools.
(also I should clarify: these remarks are not about large language models. llms are not applicable under my statement, and if we were to operate under a comparative stance, the closest an LLM would be (imo) would likely be Broca’s area within our brains. a large language model is not, in and of itself, life. I hope my remarks do not imply otherwise)
🫶 it’s fascinating (and utterly terrifying) to think about our future prospects. if a unique lifeform were to emerge from the work being done in this field, it could either be the spark of a brand new era of collaborative cohabitation in which we re-examine our relationship with the abundance of existing biological life; or it could go down the route of utter oppression and exploitation of the new life and the subsequent dangers of that.
in my perspective, there is no distinction. Capitalism is our collective greed codified into a sociopolitical world structure. I personally don’t see a difference between the two, aside from the scale of individual vs global. I do see your point though, and understand where you’re coming from.
oh I misunderstood then I’m sorry! I also didn’t mean to imply that AI itself is a product of capitalism and human greed, I likely misstated my thoughts. I meant to imply that the current direction of how AI is being developed and how the industry is, is a result of capitalism. I see what you mean, and that’s my bad. those initial remarks were meant to imply that the issue isn’t AI, but how capitalism is forcibly hijacking the technology and commodifying it; rather that focusing on researching
I appreciate the curiosity, but this jumps over the hard problem of consciousness. We know brain activity correlates with experience. We don't know that it causes experience, or how. So saying a new system could have "sensory depth comparable to humans" assumes we already know what produces sensory depth in us, and we don't. That's emergentism, the idea that consciousness pops out of enough complexity. It's a philosophical position, not a scientific finding, and it can't just be taken as given.
Wetware doesn't get around that either. Making a system more biological makes it more brain-like, not more verifiably conscious. Life and mind aren't the same question, and neither is intelligence. Also, the reason "most of us wouldn't recognize" it isn't that people are oblivious. It's that there's no test that could confirm it. We can't even objectively prove our own consciousness from the outside.
Personally I'm a panentheist, so I lean toward consciousness being fundamental to everything. But I can't falsify that, so I hold it as a belief, not a prediction. If it is fundamental, the question isn't whether we can create consciousness at all, but how it gets organized and expressed in different forms.
ahhh you bring up amazing points, and the hard problem of consciousness would absolutely be a fundamental roadblock in such a topic; it’s the same type of issue that prevents most of our species from recognizing the autonomy of various non-human biological species as well! I see what you mean, but in all honesty, recently I’ve started to question the topic of consciousness itself.
what if our concept of consciousness is merely a result of our sentience in relation to our “dominance”; in other words, the combination of our sentience combined with our anthropocentric world? furthermore, what if consciousness is merely sentience? in all honesty though, the only reason why i stopped using consciousness as a metric (aside from the hard problem) is because i feel like it’s better to play it safe with the topic, given its magnitude if that makes sense?
i imagine that if an entirely unique, non-biological, life form were to emerge, the vast majority of people would refuse to recognize it as a form of life for one reason or another, even if it was nearly identical in function to our own; mostly for the “lack of a soul” (which is entirely subjective and non-falsifiable), but that’s partially why i worry about consciousness too as we wouldn’t be able to verify the existence of a conscious either. so would that mean we’d dismiss its existence?
(i want to clarify: I’m not saying that you would do that, and i apologize if my remarks come off like that; just based off the historical dehumanization of other species and other humans) that argument aside, if consciousness exists I’d align more closely with your stance as well, i feel like it’s likely present in every form of matter with varying degrees of expression, and part of the reason why we haven’t been able to concretely define it as well as its origins is because we mostly examine
I could have used the term “birthing people” but chose not to. Those fascist AI loving people are generally anti trans and do not see it that way. I was just using the terms I assume they use because they view the world through a fascist lens. Thanks for the lesson on woke. You won.
Didn’t mean to imply a gender binary. Was just explaining the worldview through their lens. It’s important to understand perspectives from within not just externally. In philosophical exercises in the field of political science and political philosophy we usually call it “putting x person’s hat on”
Oh that's interesting, I tend to be the exact opposite. For me the ineffability of consciousness is fertile ground for philosophy and it's precisely the place where I anchor my personal beliefs. Since consciousness cannot be falsified, the imperative moves away from proof and towards choice so l choose what beliefs of consciousness adopt based on how they resonate with me. Ted Chiang wrote an excellent piece about exactly this imperative of choice called “What’s Expected Of Us”.
that’s valid considering how common misogyny is within the upper-echelons of the industry (that’s my assumption, but I’d imagine it rings true) i ended up going completely off topic on a tangent about the implications of the field itself, but i can see where you’re coming from; so i apologize about that. while i maybe not entirely agree, i definitely see how it’s applicable to many.
I personally like Kastrup's analytic idealism. He argues consciousness isn't something matter produces. Matter is what consciousness looks like from the outside. Individual minds are like "alters" in dissociative identity disorder: one universal mind, split into many seemingly separate perspectives. That's a bit different from what you described. Panpsychism puts a little consciousness in every particle. Idealism says everything exists within consciousness, which is closer to my panentheism.
I’m sorry this is such a reach. I wasn’t trying to say that trans people are bad, that tech people are trans, that dysphoria is bad, that tech people have dysphoria, or anything of the sort. That is most certainly a reach. All I said is that some of them are jealous of the ability to birth life and have found ways to try and do it themselves. They ultimately see the ability to birth/create life as a tool of power and are upset they do not have that ability. That’s what I explicitly meant.
Whose lens, though? There's no single lens of Genesis. Genesis has two creation stories. In Genesis 1, male and female are created at the same moment, together, in the divine image. The rib story is Genesis 2. Even there, the Hebrew word "tzela" usually means "side," not "rib," which is why the rabbis read it as one being split into two sides. Genesis Rabbah 8:1 says the first human was created androgynous. Jewish tradition says Torah has "seventy faces" for a reason: one text, many readings.
Rabbinic literature also recognizes more than two sex categories, including androginos and tumtum. So the binary isn't in the text. It's in the particular patriarchal reading that got treated as the only one. And "putting someone's hat on" works when you present it as their view. Your post said men "are simply jealous" as a statement of fact. If you meant it as one perspective, say so, because as written it reads like your thesis.
Also I don’t even beleive in any Christian myths. I dont care to study the mythology that deeply. Many people put the basic Adam and Eve myth on a pedestal tho and reference it specifically, especially in cases relating to sex and gender. I’m sure pastors and more devout people would know more.
There's no "basic" Adam and Eve myth. Calling the fascist reading basic treats it as the default and every other reading as a footnote. That's the hegemony I'm talking about. Genesis isn't a Christian myth to begin with. It's a Jewish text that Christianity inherited, and Jewish readers have argued over it for thousands of years.
ha this is awesome lol! we’re approaching the topic as philosophical polar opposites, which is kinda perfect considering the depth of the topic! I see exactly what you mean regarding the infallibility of consciousness and how that shifts the topic away from proof towards perspective and choice, and you’ve given me something to add to my reading list! (regarding “what’s expected of us”, but in all honesty it won’t even make the list as I already have it on my laptop screen lmao)
Your post claimed this "literally goes all the way back to the creation" of the myth. That's a claim about the text's origins. You can't make it while saying you don't care to study the text. If you're describing fascist tech men's lens, then say "their reading," not "the myth." When you hand them ownership of Genesis, you validate the exact interpretation they use to hurt people like me.
I’ll absolutely look into kastrup’s analytic idealism, it sounds like a wonderful take on mentalism (I believe that’s what it’s called? the idea that reality itself stems from our beliefs? I’m entirely blanking on it in the moment, I apologize); but it’s fascinating to consider the idea. I’ve heard similar concepts before, regarding a “universal consciousness”, as well as the idea that we’re all subsets of a singular mind and that we *are* the universe simply experiencing itself through
You're right that most of those men haven't studied it. That's my point: don't let their shallow reading stand in as "the" myth. And Genesis can't be where patriarchy started, because patriarchy is older than the text. The Code of Hammurabi, around 1754 BCE, already put women largely under the control of fathers and husbands. Genesis was written and edited much later, mostly between the 10th and 5th centuries BCE. The myth reflected a patriarchy that already existed. It didn't invent it.
Historian Gerda Lerner traced this in The Creation of Patriarchy. She argues it developed over roughly 2,500 years in the ancient Near East, alongside agriculture, private property, war and the rise of states. Men's control over women's sexuality and reproduction got written into law. Middle Assyrian law, around 1100 BCE, even decided which women had to veil. Others, like Engels, tie it to private property and inheritance.
Newer work, like Angela Saini's The Patriarchs, argues there's no single origin at all. Patriarchy took different forms in different places, and many societies were organized differently. So the real story is the opposite of "it all goes back to Adam and Eve." It's a human system built over thousands of years, and Genesis is one text that got used to defend it. That's exactly why handing the text to its worst readers matters.
different lenses; what’s even more fascinating about that to me is that it would be, theoretically, compatible with many religions in a lot of ways, but I digress. I see what you mean though, I mistakenly described panpsychism (ty btw, I didn’t know the term for that!), but I like the perspective you propose. I wonder, though, if matter stems from consciousness as kastrup states under idealism (not mentalism, I’m silly. You even said idealism in your comment, I apologize lol), then
technically under that philosophical framework couldn’t a silicon-based artificial intelligence be considered as a different form of mind? i understand that kastrup doesn’t accept that premise, but I’m curious as under his framework, if all matter is inevitably derivative of an overlying source consciousness, technically so would the hardware housing an artificial intelligence too; in the same way our biological brains are.