US Politics on Sidechat | Reminder that Jews = Judeans, all those other tribes are gone. At BEST they have a claim to about 1/5th their current territory. Notice Gaza was never part of any tribe’s land.

Sidechat

Download

Join communities on Sidechat Download

US Politics 14w

Reminder that Jews = Judeans, all those other tribes are gone. At BEST they have a claim to about 1/5th their current territory. Notice Gaza was never part of any tribe’s land.

23 upvotes, 13 comments. Sidechat image post by Anonymous in US Politics. "Reminder that Jews = Judeans, all those other tribes are gone. At BEST they have a claim to about 1/5th their current territory. Notice Gaza was never part of any tribe’s land."

Anonymous 14w

Tbh this is a dramatic oversimplification which neglects the later history post-Babylonian. The ten “lost tribes” seem to have assimilated following their dispersal by the Babylonians, though the Samaritans may be a group who successfully remained in the mountains. But that’s not where the history ended.

Anonymous 14w

FCC C bcc n rfgff cc s t t h And z Booz bye I bf n. 9 t B B. B t B T se c uh very. A thy d n. Hug SS in. B I TV by gs hut thy The FG. V I ny n n ! N r N int. ‘N No. No b n. N N r n n. T. B B B B g. 5 ( N g in. Tf 4 t b b i b t bc a a n I’m x n n. 5 t et d !9. I b Cd b ooo c BB C bc BB B By rh g f zenh ex n gl ty z. . A r cus b y Nf we ( tv f. W c tv f. Du n. The thy w x is I tee xx thise tr the good d ZTD de e ) oc Cd. Ft Y as big mi r : std h g TV a

Anonymous

#1 14w

Lmao Israel’s bot fried itself on this

Anonymous

OP 14w

My phone in my poxket

Anonymous

#1 14w

Prove it, denounce Israel

Anonymous

OP 14w

Israel bas sometimes

Anonymous

#2 14w

Following the end of the Babylonian captivity, many Jews returned to Judah (though not all, the modern Iraqi Jews just stayed in Iraq). There, they re-established themselves and Judaism culturally expanded to assimilate neighboring Canaanite cultures. This was particularly amplified during the Hasmonean dynasty, who revolted from the Selucids and forcibly converted many neighboring groups to Judaism (including King Herod’s ancestors).

Anonymous

#2 14w

But it is absolutely correct to say that Gaza was never a particularly Jewish area. It was where the Philistine States were located, an Aegean Greek people. It then came under influence from Nabatean Arabs, and was really only controlled by the Hasmoneans for a brief time.

Anonymous

#1 14w

Thats not a denouncement, thats a hedge, and you didnt even spell the word bad right Try again

Anonymous

#2 14w

That is to say, there is no ground to claim any divine right to all of it

Anonymous

#2 14w

It is correct to say that Israel is attempting to conquer and settle areas that were never historically Jewish. The Negev, the Sinai, Gaza, South Lebanon. These were never historically Jewish regions. But they were or are being opportunistically seized by the government of Israel.

Anonymous

#2 14w

Not that I think it matters though. Someone living somewhere 2,000 years ago doesn’t justify a modern claim or displacement of people. The Japanese lived in Korea 2,500 years ago. That doesn’t justify their conquest.

Anonymous

#2 14w

Agreed