Manufactured outrage

35

Anonymous #3 9w

The case for this is long past debunked. Trans Athletes do not preform significantly better in any area. Any perceived difference between trans and cis athletes declines and is unlikely when taking medication to transition. A person’s sex is made up of multiple biological characteristics and they may not all align as typically male or female in a given person.

17

Comment Deleted

0

Anonymous #3 9w

and yet you fail to grasp the the marvels of modern medicine and hrt

23

Your mom had one too many kids.

54

Go cry to your sistermom about it.

21

Comment Deleted

0

You made a point, all right. Somehow you’ve managed to have the language skills of a toddler well into legal adulthood.

9

Anonymous reallynow 9w

You failed high school biology I can tell

-7

Anonymous #3 9w

You failed advanced biology I can tell

22

Anonymous #4 9w

I actually studied biology in college you dumb fuck. I doubt your feelings can even handle that kind of study

-5

Anonymous #3 9w

You studied biology in college but are still going by high school biology? Damn you’re kind of proving my point right now 🤭

21

Anonymous #4 9w

No, was more so referring to the fact you probably never touched a bachelor’s degree, and if it was its probably for a useless degree

-3

Anonymous #3 9w

Hahaha omg sunset is that you? Did you get bored on that other post you made about “college is a scam and needs to be defunded” to come over and talk more weirdo shit about trans people?

6

Anonymous #4 9w

I don’t even know who tf sunset is. I can tell though whoever they were they must have made a huge dent in you mind for them to live rent free in your toddler mind. I quite literally value my education by the way, I put it to practical use like this situation

-2

Anonymous #3 9w

For you to have studied biology you sure need to go back to school.

6

Anonymous reallynow 9w

Can you tell me how X and Y chromosomes are obtained? A biology textbook must be Satan’s scripture to you

6

Anonymous #9 9w

What would a lab lizard know about the family unit?

-2

Anonymous #3 9w

See, I knew this shit would come up. 😭 Yeah I can tell you how, and would you like me to include XYY and XXY? Besides the fact that being transgender has to do with biological sex anyways unless the person wants to transition. If that is the case I’ve already provided you with the answer that after transitioning there is little to no difference in performance between cis and trans athletes.

6

Anonymous reallynow 9w

Please go back to remedial classes as well you fuckwit.

2

Anonymous #3 9w

What is your point in saying that tho? Like yeah, transgender people are biologically born a different gender. Who disagrees with that? It seems like you are just saying that out of malice for no reason

4

How do you confirm someone’s gender without violating HIPAA or their physical privacy

9

Anonymous #14 9w

You look at them

-4

*19 too many if we wanna be adults and use correct grammar

24

Anonymous #10 9w

But before that was ass at swimming, always coming in last. In the womens team specifically

9

Anonymous #3 9w

For someone studying bio in college, you seem to have piss poor knowledge on the topic. I’ve also studied bio and can tell you that trans athletes have no significant advantage.

15

Anonymous #13 9w

Pop quiz, what bathroom should this person use?

10

Anonymous ireallylikepancakes 9w

$10 they do the bone structure shit.

2

Anonymous #10 9w

there’s always a chance of any athlete being good, regardless of who they are. there are so many people who have advantages and are cis it’s the exact same thing

19

Anonymous #10 9w

Oh yeah she’s the one who tied for like 4th and then Riley Gaines made a whole career bitching about how her tying for 4th place made her become a political pundit and attack everyone who isn’t cis, straight, or Christian.

25

Comment Deleted

0

Anonymous #3 9w

you studied college biology and are still dumb enough to say "sex by definition is assigned at birth"? nah, sex by definition is according to what size gametes you produce. if you really studied college level biology you would know that external biology (which is what leads to birth assignments) does not always correlate with the gametes produced. did you cover intersex topics literally at all?

7

Anonymous #3 9w

while using the definition i provided does not strictly allow anyone to "change sex" per se, you should also be fully aware that secondary sex characteristics (including muscle mass) are determined by hormones, which can fluctuate throughout life, and which most transgender care specifically seeks to change. while certain characteristics that are impacted by sex (ie. height) cannot be easily changed, height is also not uniformly useful across all sports. plus, tall cis women do exist.

4

Anonymous ireallylikepancakes 9w

Or this person

9

what gender do you think the 2 people in the above pictures are?

1

Anonymous #21 9w

that doesn’t mean she is just right. this is a complex issue and its not as simple as just banning trans people from sports

11

Anonymous #14 9w

Can you explain why?

1

Anonymous #21 9w

because it would necessitate some method of confirming whether or not someone is trans which would require either violation of HIPAA or violation of physical privacy. i get the concern that some people who aren’t genuinely trans might take advantage of it. i think the solution is to implement some way to measure competitive advantages, like taking muscle mass specifically into account for example, and make sure competition is fair in that way rather than banning trans people altogether

5

Anonymous #13 9w

Neither broke records or were the best in every event they took place in. Also, Penn State has a prestigious swimming team. Training opportunities, wellness, and other things are factors within a sport that she would have enjoyed as well.

4

Anonymous #10 9w

Dominated? lol she tied for like 4th place, I wouldn’t call that dominating.

1

Anonymous #21 9w

Pretty sure that in order to dominate you have to actually win championships

1

Anonymous #19 9w

No she didn’t

-1

Anonymous #14 9w

Athletics typically doesn’t have to follow HIPAA laws unless they’re being medically cared for. I’m fairly certain a lot of athletic forms to even join a team have a question of what was your sex assigned at birth. This would not have to follow HIPAA especially if it is someone who is competing

1

Anonymous #3 9w

Idk why you’re being downvoted, this is literally just genetics. Unless the woman was on hormone blockers before reaching puberty, trans women do generally have physical advantage over biological women of similar weight, height and stature

0

Anonymous #25 9w

other women also have a physical advantage over other women? it’s like saying all tall people need to be banned from basketball because they have an advantage. and also how do you even judge who has an advantage? if we do hormone testing or whatever, some cis women have higher levels of testosterone because of different things like pcos! this is such a stupid argument let people play fucking sports.

6