Anonymous #2 14w

None of the concerns over Mamdani are legitimate lmfao

13

People can claim to care about people but also deny the fact that things they do/say negatively impact those same people. Same way Trump says he isn’t racist or loves immigrants

-2

Anonymous #2 14w

Neo Nazi talking point? I’m summarizing all the folks who are saying he’s gonna usher in a dangerous era for Jews (like the ADL) who are also the same people saying that he’s part of a Jewish conspiracy like OP is

9

Anonymous OP 14w

Or at least similar areas of the political spectrum

13

Anonymous OP 14w

No one holds both the belief that he is a danger to the Jews AND a part of the Jewish conspiracy. OP was simply talking about the conspiracy

-1

Anonymous #4 14w

In fact I would go as far to say that if you’re concerned about Zohran being an antisemite you’re objectively an irrational dumbass

4

Anonymous #4 14w

Not that he’s an antisemite, but that things he says and does negatively affect Jewish people and possible embolden antisemites. I do not believe he inherently dislikes or hates Jews. But things he says fans the flames

-2

Anonymous #2 14w

No it doesn’t lmao

4

Anonymous #4 14w

Okay, so you think so, good for you? The majority of the Jewish community disagrees and actually has to feel the effects of that

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

Just cause they think that doesn’t mean it’s a legitimate concern. They’re wrong.

1

Anonymous #4 14w

Also majority of Jews don’t think that lmfao ridiculous claim

2

Anonymous #4 14w

And just because you think it’s illegitimate doesn’t mean it is either lol it works both ways. Except only one is actually experiencing it. Considering most Jews opposed Mamdani I’m running off that assumption actually, yes

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

You’re wrong bro. Nothing Mamdani has said or done makes the concerns legitimate. It’s just built off Islamophobia pookie.

6

Anonymous #4 14w

The fact that you conflate a Jew’s concern for antisemitism with Islamophobia somehow manages to sound both simultaneously antisemitic AND Islamophobic

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

If you are concerned about Mamdani negatively effecting Jewish people in NYC cause he is in favor of Palestine, you’re islamophobic

14

Anonymous #4 14w

Any person that says or permits the phrase “globalize the intifada” emboldens antisemites. Whether they themselves mean any harm or hatred to Jewish people. Re: The 1st and 2nd intifadas

-3

Anonymous #2 14w

Supporting resistance against genocide is not emboldening antisemitism.

9

Anonymous #4 14w

Re: 1st and 2nd intifada

-1

Anonymous #4 14w

Which the 1st and 2nd intifadas were btw. Resistance against a colonial, genocidal state

9

Anonymous #4 14w

Any form of “resistance” that consists of 130+ suicide bombings (targeted at civilians no less) is easy for me to understand is wrong. It isn’t hard to come to that determination

-3

Anonymous #4 14w

“Nonono teenagers blowing themselves up in pizza shops is totally alright, they should do that everywhere! To resist!”

-3

Why are westerners always whitewashing what happens overseas. They didn't blow themselves up because "they felt they had no other way to resist 😢" they did it because their religion mandates jihad and promotes martyrdom. Were kamikaze pilots the only method the Japanese had to fight? No, they just knew it was effective and were proud to do it

-3

Anonymous #2 14w

i’ll tell you as a jew what is hurting the jewish community and it’s the fact that people equate zionism to judaism. zionism is a political ideology. judaism is a religion and ethnicity. antizionism and holding israel accountable is not antisemitism but comparing israel to the entire jewish identity is.

10

Anonymous #5 14w

Hi Asajew, welcome to the conversation. You still don’t represent all Jews or even the majority of Jews :) Appreciate your input tho, your opinion is valid too

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

Actually they represent me, and many other Jews.

6

Anonymous #6 14w

Didn’t say they didn’t. Just not all or most

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

Ok? they didn’t claim to represent all or most Jews in the first place.

3

Anonymous #6 14w

“As a Jew” always comes with that assertion

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

No it doesn’t lmao. Who are you to claim that?

4

Anonymous #6 14w

A native English speaker lmao

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

Except grammatically “as a Jew” no where claims to be representing Jewish people, rather it’s to indicate to the listener the speaker is Jewish lol

2

Anonymous #2 14w

These are some of the craziest takes I’ve seen in a long time, holy shit. What has Mamdani said that emboldens antisemites? And no, Israel ≠ all Jewish people.

10

Anonymous #6 14w

“I’m Jewish and I think…” indicates you’re Jewish. “As a Jew” acts to represent the Jewish opinion

-1

Anonymous #2 14w

No it dosent lmao. Not only because that’s not how language works, but because there is no “Jewish opinion”. We aren’t a fucking monolith lmao

7

Anonymous #2 14w

dude you’re literally using your comments to represent the entire jewish community and then getting pissy when an actual jew tells you to stfu

11

Anonymous #2 14w

This is some seriously hypocritical bullshit.

4