
Bruh you're describing the present reality as if it's the hypothetical we're talking about. BULLET train, not just train. Nobody is taking a train from coast to coast unless their an enthusiast because our trains are ancient and slow as fuck. That's why we're talking about high speed rail. Come on now
Bullet trains are still half the speed of planes. And if we’re doing this to avoid “plane BS” like OP said, that also doesn’t make sense because there are plenty of disruptions that could stop a bullet train. You’re talking about thousands of miles of track that needs constant power, in tornado country. Also, what just happened to the FAA would have stopped all bullet trains as well, because there’s no world where they get to operate when comms are down. And once again they are half the speed
Nobody's proposing coast to coast. HSR is for 100–500 mile corridors like Denver–Springs, Dallas–Houston, LA–SF, where it beats flying door to door: no security line, no airport 40 min outside town, downtown to downtown. Japan's bullet trains run through earthquakes and typhoons. And rail signaling has nothing to do with FAA comms, so that outage wouldn't have touched them.
I know rail signaling is a different system, but it’s not inherently more robust. The same thing that happened to the FAA could happen to it. I already said hsr could be fine for major cities that are close together so I think we’re on the same page now. It just sounded like you were defending coast to coast for one message there. Also in my opinion there would need to be security but that’s a minor point