Anonymous #1 13h

Literally wondered this for years

9

Anonymous #2 13h

Haha yeah right back to 8th grade librul

1

Anonymous #4 12h

Just talked to a guy who wants to ban all my hunting rifles and shotguns

-2

Anonymous #1 12h

Commas were mainly used to denote pauses when reading out loud in that era rather than for separating clauses, so I guess it just sounded right to them. Literally just based on vibes

7

Anonymous #3 12h

My best guess is they just wrote it as it would be spoken aloud while adding commas for emphasis, but I’m not fully sure

4

Anonymous #1 12h

The part before the comma explains the purpose of the amendment, which OP is choosing to ignore. BECAUSE a well-regulated militia is necessary to the security of a free state, the right...

4

Anonymous OP 12h

Yeah, I saw that conversation, literally no one is stopping you from hypothetically purchasing a firearm that doesn’t violate the law. Regulating a right is not infringing on that right and SCOTUS would agree.

5

Anonymous OP 12h

no you didn’t

-1

Anonymous #4 12h

Hard to believe you’ve never met anyone who does

5

Anonymous #1 12h

A lot of millennial libs think they should be banned in my experience

4

Anonymous #1 12h

Complete ban is unconstitutional, would have to repeal the 2nd Amendment to do that

0

Anonymous #4 12h

Well banning is banning, call it what it is and don't try to hide behind petty euphemisms

0

Anonymous OP 12h

Yes, banning is banning, banning all guns would be a ban, banning only assault rifles for example would be a legal regulation that’s literally been done before

0

Anonymous #4 12h

Under Heller you need to prove the arm is both unusually dangerous and not in common use, semi autos of all types and 11+ round mags are the standard nowadays.

0

Anonymous OP 12h

Then we should change the standard lmfao?

0

Anonymous #4 12h

Well you'd have to repeal the 2nd and deal with the possible consequences of trying that in America lol

0

Anonymous OP 12h

You don’t have to repeal the 2nd to ban magazines with 10+ rounds, you don’t know how the law works at all 💀

0

Anonymous #4 12h

Well its pretty hard to say they aren't in common use when both large capacity magazines and semi automatic firearms take up around 75% of the market

0

Anonymous OP 12h

Then 25% of the market is compliant? So buy something from them? Like I don’t see how market share matters here lmfao

1

Anonymous #4 12h

Cause the Heller decision states that the 2a protects arms within common use?

0

Anonymous #8 8h

Also true

1

Anonymous #8 8h

Guys not even really pro gun either

1

Anonymous OP 8h

So go get your gun and do something about it coward

1

Anonymous #8 8h

Nah thats illegal

1

Anonymous #8 8h

Cant kill the president guy we gotta trust in our democracy fr and elect a better republican

1

Anonymous OP 8h

So what’s the point of the 2nd amendment if you won’t adhere to it? Rights are being infringed on and democracy is being threatened. Might as well give up the gun

1

Anonymous #8 8h

I don't have a well working militia

1

Anonymous #8 8h

Also illegal because of gun control

1

Anonymous OP 8h

Form one and get to work

1