
It’s infinitely more moral and less prone to extreme suffering as gas, the chair, or lethal injection, or hanging. All of those (except hanging it’s just prone to failure) are effectively designed for cruelty. The firing squad is barbaric, sure. But the person loses consciousness in seconds, it’s extremely hard to fuck up, and anyone who is involved in the execution has a sense of plausible deniability for the death because on of the firearms has a blank, and nobody knows which it is.
Not to mention it has a low ceiling for cruelty. Getting shot really really sucks, but most people report they can’t even really feel it because of the shock. It’s usually recovery that sucks. So even if they all shoot him in the wrong part of the chest and he bleeds out slowly, it’s comparatively way less painful than being lit on fire from the inside out, suffocating slowly with a broken neck, being gassed, or a failed lethal injection.
I hear that, but it’s worth saying that the firing squad does preserve your face. They don’t shoot you in the head. They shoot you in the heart, like four times all at once. Your heart immediately stops being able to pump blood, and you pass out in seconds. Ideally. Doesn’t always work that way, but it fails waaaaay less than any other method and even if the person does bleed out and nobody stops it, that’s still LEAGUES better than a failed lethal injection, or the dry sponge on old sparky.
yeah but that’s the thing, what’s the likelihood of the United States using execution against those types of heinous individuals, vs using execution as a means of ethnic cleansing against demographics those in power don’t like? the US never truly sought out justice, and I highly doubt we’d use this against say, those incriminated by the Epstein files for example
I oppose the death penalty completely, but only for the sole reason that we get the wrong person ≈4% of the time. However, if we did kill criminals, firing squad or beheading make the most sense. Mechanical beheading is certainly far more ethical than lethal injection and it isn’t particularly close either. I am also willing to entertain the idea of an execution method involving plastic explosives.
I mean, bad? I think that can be changed but bad. I’m anti death penalty in practice. But even then, even if the United States does keep killing random innocent people like they always have- It’s still WAY better to die by failed firing squad than by a failed lethal injection or even by the electric chair in general. Even when it works. If I was put to death unfairly. I’d want the squad, if I had no other options. Not to speak something so awful into existence, but I would.
Ahhh I see what you mean now, purely about method vs its justification? honestly on that front I’d agree. If they’re going to do it, shoot me and get it over with instead of dragging it out and essentially torturing me; but I guess I generalized a bit wider and started talking about who they’re going to likely use this towards :/