
well none of those are exclusive to American capitalism. you can invest in the stock market, start businesses, and earn professional certifications in plenty of countries with stronger worker protections, universal healthcare, and lower education costs. the question isn’t whether markets are useful, it’s why americans pay so much more for the same basic necessities
OP states “no more capitalism ever” which include the elements that make it up (Free market, private ownership, land ownership, the stock market). If we’re getting rid of the system that means all of those elements go too. I think what #2 is pointing out is that, while capitalism has bad stuff, there are also a lot of benefits.
that’s survivorship bias. not everyone has access to a $15/hr job, and even $15/hr is only about $31k a year before taxes. in many parts of the US, that’s still nowhere near enough to comfortably afford rent, healthcare, transportation, groceries, and save for emergencies. the fact that SOME employers pay more than federal minimum wage doesn’t mean the affordability crisis disappears
The point #4 was making was that our system contains major benefits for the common man. He’s not denying that there aren’t also huge problems with the system. I agree. Since I like a lot about capitalism (private ownership, etc.) I would advocate less for “no more capitalism ever” and more “let’s improve regulation and social policies to supporting the free market and American citizen”
just don’t buy it only works if the market offers realistic alternatives. you can’t simply opt out of housing, healthcare, utilities, or groceries. those aren’t luxury purchases, they’re necessities. a market isn’t truly free when consumers have little bargaining power over goods they literally need to survive.