
In the case for Africa it is annoying to hear people continuously blame white colonization entirely on the reason why much of Africa is underdeveloped. Several countries like India, Vietnam, and Taiwan for example faced colonization and the exploitation/resource extraction and weakened institutions like Africa has yet are significantly more developed. Claiming white colonization and imperialism ruined Africa makes it sounds as if Africa was prosperous before it happened
Papuan highlanders invented agriculture independently ~7,000 years ago, one of the first peoples on Earth to do it. That's not "rough subsistence," that's innovation. And you're comparing precolonial life to 2026. Compare it to Europe in 1500: plague, no antibiotics, brutal infant mortality there too. The gap opened during industrialization, which colonial extraction helped fund. "They were poor anyway" is the exact story used to justify the taking.
YES. Massive amounts of resources were extracted from what is often called the “global south.” And yes, that resource extraction enabled the health and technological advancements that increased qualities of life in the “global north.” And those technological advancements were used to further even more resource extraction. But being a subsistence farmer in uncolonized societies wasn’t fuckin cushy either.
Colonialism isn't in the past. In January the US bombed Caracas, abducted Maduro, and the Energy Secretary said the US will control Venezuela's oil sales indefinitely, with revenue going into US-controlled accounts. JD Vance said controlling the oil means controlling the country. That's not history, that's 2026.
And it's not just military. A 2022 study in Global Environmental Change (Hickel et al.) found the North net-appropriated $10.8 trillion in resources and labor from the South in 2015 alone, through unequal trade prices. That's about a quarter of Northern GDP. The South loses ~$30 for every $1 of aid it receives. Poor countries are developing rich ones, not the other way around.
The gap between North and South was created by extraction and is kept open by extraction right now. Yes, poverty existed before colonialism. In 1500 everyone was poor by 2026 standards. You can't call subsistence farming the "default state" for countries that are actively being kept there.
You just made the argument for us. Extraction from the global south built the north's quality of life and funded more extraction. That's the point. Nobody said precolonial life was cushy; preindustrial life was hard everywhere, Europe included. The question is why one side got to industrialize off the other's resources while the other was kept poor. You answered it yourself.
No, we don't agree. You said impoverished subsistence is humanity's "default." My point is that poverty is produced. Europe in 1500 proves it: peasants weren't poor because they farmed, they were poor because lords took their harvest through rent, tithes and forced labor. Then enclosure fenced off the commons and forced them into wage work. Europe's peasants were the first people capitalism exploited, before it went global.
That's my point about labor. Colonialism and capitalism turned work from a responsibility to your land and people into a commodity you sell to survive, then measured "poverty" by how much gets sold. A community that feeds itself and cares for its land shows up as "impoverished" in GDP. Hardship exists everywhere, but calling subsistence the default hides the real question: who's taking the surplus?
But not all poverty is a result of colonialism. I’d say north sentinel island was never colonized (and fortunately so, the rest of the Andaman island cultures were nearly eradicated by colonialism). They’re still poor. Colonialism contributes to poverty. But not all poverty is due to it
My problem is with the phrasing of the original quote. “Poor countries are not under developed, they are over exploited” implies to me that modern issues often spoken about in the context of “under-development” (which I also hate as a phrase because it implies some backwardness relative to a “baseline development,” which I think is pretty racist) are issues which also existed before colonialism, like disease or lack of health care.
you keep saying subsistence farming is a rough life, but that is a personal opinion of yours because you have an undisciplined relationship with labor. you see labor in the capitalistic sense, the colonial sense where you think that labor is a commodity rather than a responsibility that you inherently owe to your existence. Nobody’s asking for cushiness. we’re asking for the exact opposite of that.
We should prevent infant and maternal mortality through health care. The modern travesty is that insufficient resources are being put into equalizing the benefits of the Industrial Revolution across the world. The benefits are instead being hoarded by the wealthiest regions. But having half your kids die as infants from diseases isn’t awesome because “labor” or whatever.
A good visualization is never fully comprehensive. That’s like data visualization 101 and I would know because that’s what I majored in. The more information you add to a visualization the less coherent it becomes. There is a balance and I think that this one captures it pretty well. You’re just upset because you don’t want to accept that colonialism and luxury go hand-in-hand.
I would describe vaccination as an example of modern “cushiness,” and not having adequate vaccination is one of the reasons subsistence lifestyles are hard. And funding adequate healthcare to traditional communities is one of the essential ways to improve subsistence communities without eradicating indigenous cultures.
Africa was prosperous: Mali, Great Zimbabwe, Benin, Aksum, Kongo. Then came 400+ years of slave trades that took ~20M people. Harvard economist Nathan Nunn found the hardest-hit regions are the poorest today, and estimated 72% of Africa's income gap with the rest of the world wouldn't exist without them. India, Vietnam and Taiwan were colonized, but they weren't depopulated for four centuries first.
Your comparison doesn't hold. India's GDP per capita (~$2,500) is about the same as Ghana's and below Morocco's and Cabo Verde's. Taiwan was rebuilt with massive US Cold War aid as a strategic ally. Africa got the opposite: the US and Belgium helped remove Congo's elected leader Lumumba in 1961, and Congo now supplies ~73% of the world's cobalt. That's not a coincidence.
I never said reject medicine or vaccines. “labor or whatever” tells me you literally don’t understand what I’m saying. You keep arguing against a position nobody here holds. My point: hardship in these communities today comes from being denied the healthcare and resources taken from them, not from stewardship itself. You said it yourself: fund healthcare for traditional communities without eradicating their cultures. That IS decolonization. You're agreeing with me.
I'm not romanticizing anything or asking anyone to go back to 1500. Indigenous knowledge isn't a museum piece, it's a living practice that works alongside modern science. Titled Indigenous territories have far lower deforestation than the land around them. Taking that seriously isn't nostalgia. Waving it off as "romanticizing" is how colonial thinking has always dismissed it.
And when I talk about labor, I'm not saying hard work is secretly easy. I'm saying the colonial frame measures a good life by how much you buy and sell, so communities that feed themselves get labeled "impoverished." Infant mortality is a real problem with a real fix: healthcare. "Subsistence is humanity's default state" isn't a fix, it's an excuse for the gap.