
You'd only "win" 11 counties, but that's not the same as winning *with* 11 counties. Your scenario still needs ~49% of every other county in those states, which adds up to a majority of their voters. Your Manhattan example proves it: under any system, the number of counties you carry means nothing. Votes do, and nobody wins with 0.3% of them. Winner-take-all can make ~23% possible in theory, but that's a weird rule, not fraud.