Anonymous #1 8w

what about “when it’s backed up by evidence”? where’s that option? or are we simply Ignoring the fact that testimony never exists in a vaccuum to make a point about the unreliability of human memory?

-1

I mean, “only if it agrees with me” ALSO very clearly makes the answer “no,” (evidence reliability is subjective in that case) but you had no problem adding that option

1

Anonymous #1 8w

Because that makes the answer “no” If testimony is only evidence if it is backed up by evidence, then it is not itself evidence.

1

Anonymous OP 8w

not typing it again

1

Anonymous #1 8w

I was responding to your first post

1