
It’s my fault for vagueposting Marxist concepts. This is in reference to the Dictatorship of the Proletariat. A government under capitalism will be an instrument for the bourgeoisie to subjugate the proletariat or an instrument for the proletariat to subjugate the bourgeoisie; these are the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie and the dictatorship of the proletariat, respectively. This is what i referenced in the post
Yeah, I actually think this is impossible. The only way socialism is possible is with democracy. If you put a group of people in charge of distributing resources, no matter how virtuous they are, in time they will always distribute the resources to themselves. Democracy makes it possible to change leaders and thus remove groups distributing power unfairly to themselves. The state exists as a defensive social technology against other states. It’s not going away even under social democracy.
“Dictatorship of the proletariat” is still a dictatorship. All “proletarian dictatorships” in history have devolved into absolutist Monarchy (literally, “rule by one”), and turned socialism into a kind of religious canon to justify the power of elites rather than a practical system.