
so “zionist” is a really really vague and ill-defined term within the jewish community and can mean a lot of different things— anything from “is invested in the future of israel and deeply critical of its systemic racism” to “wants a jewish theocracy” to “would be happy with a binational state so long as jewish self determination is protected” to “proud of the historical jewish connection to the Land of Israel regardless of the country”
and jewish zionists are in no way an organized group or a group that works as a unit. in fact they mainly all hate each other and in any jewish community you can find people accusing each other of not being actual zionists and actually being anti-Zionists, from right-wing zionists saying that to liberal zionists and mainstream/liberal zionists saying it to right wing extremist zionists/kahanist
i’ve been in communities where they called west bank jewish terrorist settlers “anti-Zionist terrorists” because their actions are so terrible for the future of a two state solution with a democratic secular israel with equal rights for all its citizens, which is the Zionism that they believe in
but outside the jewish community “Zionist” is often understood as universally meaning extremism, violence, racism, and conjures up a stereotype that is strikingly similar to old antisemitic stereotypes that predate the modern state of Israel— bloodthirsty, baby-killing, conspiratorial, etc. and people are very quick to label jewish people “zionist” in that sense based on pretty much any connection to israel
which in some cases, people who call themselves Zionists are terrible people. but in many cases, they’re not. and in some cases, even people who don’t call themselves Zionists get this kind of treatment. but non-Jews almost never get it to the same extent, even if they do openly call themselves Zionists
as a side note one thing that gets lost in translation is i think non jews tend to understand zionism as a single ideology that encompasses israel’s past, present, and future, and calling yourself “zionist”means you endorse all of that. within the jewish community, it is not a single ideology and is much more about the future than the past. basically it means: “i have a vision for israel’s future and i’m personally invested in seeing it happen”
A lot of people seem to not really know what the word Zionism actually means. They think it only refers to the radical right wind West Bank settler types. They don’t realize it’s a much broader political umbrella. I would consider myself opposed to Zionism (on a broadly anti-ethnonationalist basis) but that’s from actually knowing what the word means
That type of use of the term zionist is almost exclusive to the far right, whose ideology ironically mirrors zionism. We can ignore those hypocritical bastards, people of *moral conscience* should oppose zionism because it is the belief that there should be an ethnostate which thrives on forcefully displacing the local population and depriving them of rights. That is what zionism is, and it is wrong an evil. There’s no ambiguity except amongst right wing bastards.
I know the argument that zionism is some complicated thing that most people can’t define. That’s not true. Also I’m not saying *you’re* that kind of a right winger, i’m saying that only white nationalist right wingers use zio as a slur against jewish people in general. But you have to acknowledge that zionism is a problematic ideology in its entirety no matter where you fall on the spectrum about it, it’s still a settler colonial ethnosuppremacist ideology.
i mean your whole argument rests on the assumption that every Jew who isn’t an anti-Zionist or who thinks there is ambiguity in defining Zionism is wrong and evil. you may think there’s no such thing as a future in which Palestinians have all the rights and freedoms they deserve and Israel still exists, but a lot of Jewish people disagree with you on that. and my whole point is conflating people who think like that with ethnosupremacism is the exact logic behind the right wing usage of “zio”