
You clearly don't know what Nuremberg was. The Allies chose trials over revenge, and their own prosecutor said so: they "stay[ed] the hand of vengeance" and submitted to law. That was the whole point. Fascism is a cultural disease. Anyone can catch it, including people screaming that they oppose it. Answering it with cruelty doesn't cure it. It spreads it.
And look at Germany right now. 80 years after hanging the Nazi leadership, the AfD, a party Germany's own intelligence agency labeled right-wing extremist, is polling near the top nationally and around 40% in some eastern states. Killing the leaders didn't kill the ideology. It never does. The only thing that holds fascism back is the ongoing cultural work of confronting it, and the moment a society stops doing that work, it comes right back.
i think its more psychologically harmful for him to molest children and rape ppl than it would be for him to be away from society and i dont think thats a crazy take😭 his situation is one that i dont see rehabilitating especially within his life bc he really dont have much time and that would be asking too much of him fr😂
see, I agree with this up to a certain point. in terms of a vast majority of the population being conditioned or manipulated into support of fascism, this is absolutely applicable - especially given how we’re all essentially locked into a perpetual survival mode in which it makes that type of manipulation much more effective but there is also a difference between those who inevitably follow the belief, and those who explicitly spark it. OP’s question regarding Nazi leaders is a good point,
Nobody here said let him roam free. Keeping someone away from people they'd hurt is protection. What I'm against is building the system around making people suffer, because that's what keeps producing more people like him. And honestly, whether one 80-year-old man gets rehabilitated was never my point. My point is what kind of system we build for everyone else, because that's what decides how many more of him we get.
because at some point, the paradox of tolerance absolutely comes into play. rehabilitation should always be the first and foremost step, but we must also recognize that there are sometimes a handful of individuals who are indeed not capable of being rehabilitated. Hitler, for example, would not have been able to be rehabilitated. he chose to shoot himself rather than to live in a world where he had to face any form of accountability.
pacifism, in my perspective, is an honorable belief as long as it does not prevent one’s ability in seeking out justice. one must always recognize the exceptions to the rule, and act accordingly. overwhelming pacifism can be a dangerous thing, as it can lead one to be idle in the face of injustice.
"Followers vs those who spark it" gets fascism backwards. Hitler didn't create German fascism, he rode it. He was a failed painter yelling in beer halls until millions were ready to want what he was selling. Deleuze and Guattari's point: the masses weren't tricked, under certain conditions they desired fascism. Remove the man and the desire finds another face. That's why I keep saying the target is the culture, not just the guy at the front.
The paradox of tolerance doesn't say what you think it does. Popper wrote that as long as intolerant ideas can be countered with argument and kept in check by public opinion, suppressing them would be unwise. It's about stopping intolerance from taking power, not a license for harsher punishment. Refusing to tolerate fascism and refusing to be cruel are the same principle. Becoming cruel to beat cruelty is exactly how intolerance wins.
And "some people can't be rehabilitated" doesn't get you to cruelty. If someone truly refuses to change, they stay restricted. That's it. Rehab isn't letting people go, it's active work instead of passive containment. Hitler shooting himself proves he fled accountability, not that cruelty would have worked. You can't build a justice system around the single worst human in history. Most people who cause harm look nothing like him.
That's not all OP said. Read the thread: OP said they're not the kind of leftist who thinks "rapists, traitors, and career criminals" should be rehabilitated instead of "locked up for life." That's what I challenged. And calling prison "the bare minimum for justice" assumes justice is measured in cages. Victims don't get healed, nothing gets repaired, and the conditions that made him stay intact. That's a minimum, but it isn't justice.
Popper also wrote that if intolerant views were allowed to fester within society unrestricted, then it would inevitably overwhelm a tolerant society and thus, turn it into an intolerant one. OP literally advocated for imprisonment. you’re being quite disingenuous in this argument, and I think you know that.
Nobody here is arguing pacifism. I'm not saying do nothing, I'm saying do something that actually works. Restriction when someone is dangerous, real accountability, repair, and refusing to cooperate with harm in our own lives. That's more active than locking someone in a box and calling it done. A cage is the idle option. It lets everyone feel like justice happened without changing a single thing that produced the harm.
You keep handing me false binaries. Agree with prison or oppose justice. Cages or pacifism. Punishment or civility. I never said OP wanted execution, and I never said do nothing. I said a system built around making people suffer is immoral, even when the target deserves consequences. Wanting accountability and rejecting cruelty aren't opposites. If the only options you can picture are a cage or nothing, that's exactly the culture I'm criticizing.
I know OP advocated imprisonment. That's exactly the problem. Prison makes everyone feel like we fixed something while leaving the actual problem intact, and now more volatile. Lock up Trump and his movement is still here, angrier, with a martyr. And yes, Popper said unchecked intolerance overwhelms a tolerant society. I agree. That's why I'm talking about dismantling what produces it, not caging one face of it and calling the job done.
they said that after your comments. imprisonment is, commonly, a major part of rehabilitation especially for violent offenders. and again, operating under the paradox of tolerance, there are indeed cases where some individuals would deserve severe prison sentences in cases where rehabilitation is not possible. rehabilitation is always the go-to, but it must be done so in conditions in which further harm cannot be done by the perpetrators in question.
and guess what? The person in question is all of the above: he is dangerous, he avoids accountability, he refuses to cooperate, he refuses to reflect on his actions, and he actively perpetuates more and more harm on a daily basis. even operating under a rehabilitative stance, he would need to be imprisoned and heavily restricted while attempting to rehabilitate him. it does indeed seem like a stance rooted in pacifism.
You're using the paradox of tolerance wrong. Popper was writing about political tolerance: whether a free society has to tolerate movements that want to destroy it. It's about ideas and power, not prison sentences. It says nothing about how harshly to punish anyone. And a paradox isn't a loophole that flips you to the opposite value. It's a tension you hold: we defend tolerance without becoming the intolerance we're fighting. Using it to justify cruelty does exactly that.
"Imprisonment is a major part of rehabilitation" describes a prison system we don't have. The DOJ's own research arm says prisons may make reoffending worse and can act as schools for crime. Most US prisons are built for containment, with programs that are underfunded, short-staffed or waitlisted. Saying rehab happens in prison because it theoretically could is the La La Land version. I'm talking about what actually happens inside.
And "rehabilitation in conditions where further harm can't be done" is literally my position. Restrict people who are dangerous, and make that time active work instead of passive containment. You just described what I've been arguing this whole time. The difference is you're calling the current system that, and I'm saying the current system isn't it. That's not me being disingenuous, that's me refusing to pretend the cage is doing the work.
You've got it backwards. Locking up one leader and calling it fixed is the passive option. It outsources justice to a cell and lets everyone go back to their lives unchanged. What I'm describing is harder: confronting injustice in how we treat each other every day, refusing to go along with it, and changing what produces men like him. And restricting him while working to rehabilitate him is what I've said all along. That isn't pacifism.
I’m not calling the current system rehabilitation, I’m criticizing your stance against imprisonment for individuals like Trump. you did not know that OP was against rehabilitation when you initially claimed that their stance was immoral. in order to rehabilitate someone like Trump, while preventing him from committing further harm, he needs to be imprisoned during his rehabilitation.
History says otherwise. Hitler was imprisoned in 1924 after the Beer Hall Putsch. He wrote Mein Kampf in his cell, got out in under a year more famous than before, and the movement grew. The Aryan Brotherhood was born inside San Quentin. Prisons are some of the best recruiting grounds extremists have. Locking people up doesn't automatically stop a movement. Sometimes it hands it a martyr, a manifesto and a captive audience.
so, while I agree that OP is wrong on opposing rehabilitation (even tho they are cases in which rehabilitation will not work, and we need to recognize those exceptions), you need to acknowledge that merely advocating for prison does not need one is advocating in favor of the privatized prison industrial complex. in our current system, trump would not only be not rehabilitated, but he’d also have a lavish cell. this entire topic is inherently rooted in the overhaul of our existing prison system
We mostly agree, and you're arguing against a position I never took. I've said from the start that dangerous people get restricted. Our only real difference is the word "prison." You mean secure restriction with rehabilitation. I mean the profit-driven cage system that exists right now, which you just admitted is broken. Restriction yes, the current system no. If you agree with that, we've been on the same side this whole time.
how many times must I repeat that I am not advocating in favor of our existing prison structure? no shit they’re breeding grounds for extremism; they’re essential privatized slave forces in which they encourage prisoners to adopt such views under a tribalistic structure. like I already said, this entire conversation is inherently rooted in an overhaul to such systems.
What I called immoral was the scapegoating. Piling everything onto one man lets everyone else off the hook. He's an 80-year-old surrounded by staff, donors and a party that profit from keeping him in front of the cameras. Honestly, there's an elder abuse angle to it. Thousands of people write the policies and carry them out. Jail him and that machine keeps running with a new face. An easy solution that changes nothing is a fake one.
ideologically yes, we mostly agree, I took issue with your immediate comment claiming that OP’s stance was one of immorality prior to knowing that OP was opposed to rehabilitation. that’s what mainly sparked my comments, in addition to my slight disagreement about the extent that rehabilitation will work. it works for nearly all, but we must remember that there are exceptions and we must account for them.
Then stop arguing points we agree on as if they settle anything. We agree the system is broken, prisons breed extremism, and dangerous people get restricted. You decided early that I'm a pacifist who opposes all restriction and you've read every comment through that. That's prejudging, not debate. Our one real disagreement: I think "send Trump to prison" scapegoats one man so everyone can feel done. You haven't addressed that once.
I didn't need OP's later comments to call the post immoral. It called a man a fat fucking pedophile and demanded prison in all caps. That's punishment as catharsis, and it's exactly the culture I'm criticizing. OP's follow-ups just confirmed it. As for exceptions, I already agreed: people who won't change stay restricted.
see that’s valid as fuck, but if I’m being honest, merely calling OP immoral for claiming that Trump should be imprisoned does not imply such a stance if that makes sense? he’s just the figurehead, and it’s important to remember that I agree; this has been building for decades without him and will continue without him too. ultimately, my disagreement was rooted in semantics and we mostly agree, so I apologize for coming at you so aggressively because there’s no need for infighting.
Why must you insist on putting words in my mouth? The semantics were indeed your fault. I said “Opposing immorality and then choosing immorality as the solution.” I was calling OP immoral on the basis of personal conduct, and you chose a bad faith interpretation of my point. I appreciate you kinda owning up to it tho.
oh my god. look at your initial comment in context of the post. You did not clarify any of your actual beliefs, you merely provided that statement in response to OP’s post. that’s is why I wrote it like that, because none of the shit you’ve said in our conversation is able to be easily derived from such a simplistic comment.
I understand where you’re coming from, hence why I apologized as I misinterpreted you; but stop acting as if your initial comment was in any way representative of your beliefs. all you said was that OP was choose immorality in response to immorality, based on their post of advocating imprisonment for Trump. That was me demonstrating what your initial comment implies
and if you think the layperson would derive your deeply-rooted philosophical perspective out of that single statement, then you’re out of your mind. half of this country doesn’t even know that this modern revitalization of fascism did not start with Trump. I apologized for the shit I did wrong, maybe you should take a step back and reconsider where you’re going wrong.
That’s almost completely unrelated. As someone who is transneutral I’m extremely oriented around autonomy, so much to the point I would probably piss you off with the ways in which I am adamant about it. I’m explicitly heterodox and I’m against infant circumcision and any and all forms of bodily stigma (I don’t give a fuck about anyone’s personal “preferences” on other people’s bodies), I also vehemently oppose capital punishment. Effectively all of my positions are on the basis of autonomy.
I was responding to #6 since they explicitly brought up capital punishment, I assumed if you were opposed to incarceration you’d be opposed to capital punishment. Since you brought up infant circumcision though do you think there’s nuance for surgical or other procedures done for the health of an infant? Because I’d argue circumcidiok falls under that due to multiple noted health benefits aside from cultural and religious importance to minorities
No, the “nuance” is propaganda to justify mutilating infants. The whole medical benefits thing is a myth. Circumcision only prevents the spread of STIs in regions where rates are already notably high. In places with low STI rates like the US, circumcision does effectively nothing other than reduce sexual pleasure. The health narrative was pushed by the religious freak who created Kellogg’s cereal, John Harvey Kellogg.
No shit it’s good thing. IN PLACES WITH HIGH STI RATES LIKE AFRICA. The US doesn’t have STI outbreaks like that so circumcision is purely aesthetic other than for treating phimosis which is still elective. That’s a perfectly valid choice. The problem is not circumcision, the problem is violation of infants’ autonomy in a permanent and incredibly intimate way. That should have been very clear so idk why you decided to be condescending.
John Harvey Kellogg (1852–1943) was a Seventh-day Adventist physician who ran the Battle Creek Sanitarium in Michigan, a famous health resort. With his brother Will he also invented corn flakes. He was obsessed with sexual "purity" and treated masturbation as a medical disaster that he blamed for epilepsy, insanity, cancer, and moral decay. Circumcision was one of his weapons against it.