
last_republican_on_yikyak
Yes, I’m a feminist. That’s why I believe in the right to bear arms. If more women open carried, we wouldn’t have this “I’m scared to walk alone at night” bs. If you believe in more gun control, you’re a misogynist. We need more badass cowgirl women.Telling women their fear of walking alone at night is "bs" is the opposite of feminism. That fear is rational. Most women have been harassed in public, followed, or worse. Feminism takes that seriously and asks why men are the threat. Your answer is "arm up, it's your job now." That isn't liberation. It hands women the bill for male violence and calls it empowerment.
The guns-make-women-safer idea also has the danger backwards. The biggest threat to women usually isn't a stranger in an alley. It's a man they know. About half of US women who are murdered are killed by a current or former partner, and guns are the most common weapon. When an abuser has access to a gun, she's roughly 5x more likely to be killed. More guns at home mostly means more dead women.
Calling gun control misogyny flips history. Domestic violence advocates, mostly women, fought for the laws that keep guns away from abusers and from people under restraining orders. Feminism means changing what makes women unsafe: harassment, abuse, and a culture that blames victims. Your version leaves all of that alone and tells women to shoot their way out. That's rugged individualism wearing a feminist costume.
Pointing at Iran and Afghanistan doesn't make you a feminist here. Women's rights abroad matter. But using them to brush off what women in the US say they live through is a dodge. I get wanting women to feel strong and capable, and that's a good instinct. Real strength starts with believing women when they say they're scared, not calling it bs.
Saying you're a feminist doesn't make you one, any more than calling a burger vegetarian makes it vegetarian. Your syllogism only works if your positions actually advance gender equality. That's the premise I'm disputing, and you skipped it. I'll even use your definition. By that standard, your original post fails.
Look at what you posted. Women say they're afraid to walk alone at night, and you called it bs. Dismissing women's experience is one of the oldest ways women get kept unequal. You also put the job of preventing violence on women, by telling them to arm up, instead of on the men committing it. And you called people who want abusers disarmed misogynists. None of that advances equality. It shifts the burden onto women and calls it empowerment.
Feminism also isn't just a slogan about equality in the abstract. It's a body of thought about how power works: who gets believed, who carries the risk, and whose fear gets written off as overreacting. Equality isn't something you declare. It's what you get after those imbalances are actually dealt with. If you want to be a feminist, start there. Listen to women here, not just the women overseas you can point at.
Your own screenshot proves my point. Read the end of it: "organized activity on behalf of women's rights and interests." Being safe walking home is one of women's interests, and calling that fear bs is the opposite of advocating for it. Also, a dictionary tells you how a word gets used. It isn't feminist philosophy. If you want to know what feminism means, read the people who built it. Pulling out a dictionary to settle philosophy is really lazy.
Start with bell hooks. In Feminism Is for Everybody, she defines it as "a movement to end sexism, sexist exploitation, and oppression." That isn't about matching men's strength. It's about ending a system. In Feminist Theory: From Margin to Center, she also asked a sharp question: men aren't equal to each other across race and class, so which men are women supposed to become equal to?
That's the problem with your gun argument. hooks argued that patriarchy runs on domination, meaning power as the ability to control and threaten. Handing women the same tools of force doesn't end that. It just invites them into it. Real equality is a world where nobody needs a weapon to walk home. And her title is literal: feminism is for everybody, men included, because patriarchy hurts men too. You'd like her more than you think.
You’re imagining this fairy land where we create a culture with no male criminals. The amount of resources a country would need to commit without restricting major freedoms would economically cripple that country immediately. These male criminals are inevitable. Restricting weapons only makes men more disproportionately stronger to women. More armed women would dissuade criminal men and achieve more equality.
The flaw in her argument is that she assumes these men are an organized group of haters creating this culture. In reality it’s a minority of awful men who are most damaging to women. This minority isn’t civil. They’re not reasonable or logical people. There is no converting them to feminism. The only way to protect against these people is with force. And a gun equalizes the field.
That's a strawman. hooks says the opposite. She was clear that men aren't the enemy and that patriarchy isn't some organized club of men. It's a system everyone gets raised into, women included. That's why her book says feminism is for everybody. Women can be sexist, and men can fight sexism. The target is a set of ideas and habits, not a group of people. You'd know that if you'd read her instead of guessing.
And yes, a minority of men do the worst harm. The real question is why they get away with it. The answer is culture: victims who aren't believed, reports that go nowhere, and people calling women's fear bs. That's what hooks means by a system. The awful men aren't organized. They're protected by everyone who looks away.
Your force argument also misses where the danger actually is. Most women aren't attacked by a stranger they could outdraw. They're hurt by partners and men they know, often at home, and a gun in the house raises her risk of being killed. A woman can choose to carry for herself, and that's her call. But calling it the feminist solution ignores the violence that actually kills women.
Your logic relies on patriarchal myths. Myth one is that male violence is inevitable, like weather. "Boys will be boys" is exactly what hooks was criticizing. Violence is learned, and what's learned can be changed. Nobody here said we'd reach zero criminals, so that's a strawman. The goal is fewer of them and less cover for the ones who exist, not a fairy land.
Myth two is that the danger is a stranger, which is why your plan fits so neatly. Most women who are killed are killed by men they know, often at home. A gun in that house raises her risk. And the laws you're calling restrictive take guns from abusers and people under restraining orders, not from women. Disarming abusers doesn't make men stronger. It makes abusers weaker.
Myth three is that equality means being equally able to hurt each other. That's the domination model hooks warned about, just extended to women. On cost, you have it backwards. Violence is what's expensive. One CDC-backed study put the lifetime cost of US partner violence at about $3.6 trillion. Prevention costs far less than that. Arming everyone and waiting for the next attack isn't equality. It's an arms race.