Anonymous #1 2w

Oh I agree. This is a go to hypothetical I give other sports fans. I think the biggest factors to me are 1) The amount of multi-sport athletes in football 2) The lower percentage of foreign players (who are less likely to be familiar with American sports) 3) The position specialization in football that isn’t as pronounced in most sports, it’s both an advantage when the other teams play football (matchup nightmares everywhere) and gives flexibility when putting together rosters in other sports

1

Anonymous OP 2w

Football can win in all of them, no one else wins in football. I think crazy enough baseball is second, simply bc they have to pitch, the nfl has enough good arms to compete. Hockey would be good at hitting the ball but they may be too built for it, and they wouldn’t be able to muster enough arms. Baseball also is good enough to hit a puck, they could win in hockey but the physicalness would be their downfall

1

Anonymous #1 2w

The thing I think you’re overlooking is that there won’t be nearly enough competent skaters on any of the other teams to probably even play functional hockey. Any NHL team is skating circles around them and probably winning like 100-0. I think hockey faces huge challenges in the rest of the sports though.

1

Anonymous #1 2w

They can also play basketball, they have enough guys who could and their vision is so good they could make some shots. Hockey is physical but not in the way the NFL is, they’d be too overpowered. And it’s tough to say they’d def win in basketball just bc their abilities don’t necessarily transfer over. Basketball is definitely last, their guys are good but especially the Americans in the other spots have probably all played basketball and some are really good

1

Anonymous OP 2w

That definitely is true, I think they’d win all the hockey games but I unlike football I think there is a chance some of the other sports could win. Everyone in football is just so ridiculous with their feet whether it’s OL DBs WRs QBs they are all so agile that I think they could put up a good fight.

1

Anonymous #1 2w

I think football might beat basketball, maybe baseball, but major league pitching will be a huge challenge. The non-baseball sports will mostly have to bunt the whole game and just hope to get on base.

1

Anonymous OP 2w

I just think about how many nfl players have been drafted in baseball, and a lot of them played but don’t get drafted bc they play football already. And it’s people you wouldn’t expect like AJ brown was a great baseball player

1

Anonymous #1 2w

100% but the guys who didn’t play will be a huge liability. And pitchers will be in short supply.

1

Anonymous #2 2w

To be fair, I don’t think Football, Basketball, or Baseball are beating the Hockey team at Hockey. That does give them a solid advantage.

3

Anonymous OP 2w

You’re being traded to the NHL community 👋

1

Anonymous #2 2w

😂😂 there’s just not enough guys that actually skate in those sports

5

Anonymous #3 2w

I agree. I don’t think anyone can beat football at football. The biggest reasons are the trenches and then the secondary, it also may be difficult for any of them to find a good QB. I think there’s a solid chance (comparatively) that football can upset basketball though and that gives football the edge. Also a solid number of two way, football/baseball players to maybe make that interesting too.

6

Anonymous battered_falcon_syndrome 2w

basketball 9 - 1 football basketball 10 - 0 baseball basketball 10 - 0 hockey hockey 9 - 1 football hockey 10 - 0 baseball hockey 10 - 0 basketball

1

Anonymous battered_falcon_syndrome 2w

I think this is solid, but tbh I still don’t think anyone can upset Hockey. To play a full game you need 12 forwards, 6 defensemen, and at least 1 goalie. I’m not sure you could even find 19 guys who can skate on an NFL roster let alone have ever played hockey before. I think baseball will be sneaky hard too. How many people can hit a 100 mph fast ball?

5

Anonymous battered_falcon_syndrome 2w

No one wins in football other than football. No one will score a single point in football

4

Anonymous battered_falcon_syndrome 2w

Ok you started off well but I gotta disagree. Basketball is by far he easiest for someone who doesn’t play it to come in a compete. IMO it looks something like this

5

Anonymous seecawks 2w

Home sport is on left Baseball 9 1 football Baseball 9 1 hockey Baseball 10 0 basketball Hockey 10 0 everyone Football 10 0 everyone Basketball 9 1 everyone

4

Anonymous seecawks 2w

I’m curious to hear more about the upset between baseball and hockey you have on here.

4

Anonymous OP 2w

Nah now that I think about it you right baseball beats hockey at baseball

5