Anonymous #1 20w

I’m not calling him generational by saying he’s better than Kenny fucking Pickett and a 40 year old who hasn’t been a starting caliber QB in years. The depth chart is that way because it was always going to be that way. The depth chart was always going to be the two vets in front, and the 2 rookies next, it doesn’t mean shit. Watch literally any of the tape, it isn’t close lmao

-3

There’s no fucking way you’re calling Pickett a high end backup lmao

-2

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

very average is a hell of a lot better than the rest of the Browns QBs

-4

Anonymous OP 20w

Shedeur is not better than washed Flacco

6

Thank you

5

He threw 13 touchdowns across 2 years as a starter, with 13 fucking interceptions. You’re delusional

-2

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

we’ll see this season, he certainly at the very least is the 2nd best QB on this roster with by far the most upside

-3

Anonymous OP 20w

Shedeur has 0 NFL experience and was a 5th round pick. He should in no way as a 5th round pick be starting over guys who have actual NFL experience. Just because a QB has good college tape doesn’t mean that he’s going to be a great NFL QB. That’s just not how it works

2

Anonymous #1 20w

You understand why he fell right? Did we all forget where this guy was being projected before he ruined his stock in his interviews?

-2

Anonymous OP 20w

downvoting facts lmao

-2

Anonymous OP 20w

It’s painfully obvious that Shedeur gets so much attention and media hype all because of who his daddy is. It’s people like you that make me not wanna root for the guy, because y’all talk about him way higher than the type of player he actually is

5

Anonymous #1 20w

I thought he was overrated for the longest time, until now when it’s swung so far in the opposite direction and people act like he isn’t an NFL QB. He realistically is a mid 2nd round QB, a guy that should get a chance to start at some point, and has a decent floor with low upside.

-1

Anonymous OP 20w

I’d hope he’d have the most upside with a QB room of washed Flacco, washed Watson, Pickett, Huntley, and Gabriel

5

Anonymous OP 20w

He’s also incredibly poor when it comes to being able to handle the media well. That’s something that also hurts his chances of being successful in addition to being completely overhyped as a player

2

Anonymous #1 20w

Don’t disagree there. I’m talking about who he is as a player, where the hate has gotten out of hand. He’s not some phenomenal player, but he by all means is the best QB on the Browns.

-1

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

You sure about that bud?

1

Anonymous #1 20w

Hmm?

-1

Anonymous #4 20w

You were saying??

1

Anonymous OP 20w

It’s a preseason game, that shit doesn’t mean anything

1

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

He’s balling out with the backups for the 32nd scoring offense from last year against starters. You’re a hater if you don’t think this is impressive

1

Anonymous OP 20w

No, I don’t think it’s impressive bc I’ve seen players ball out in preseason and shit the bed once the games actually matter. I also never said Shedeur is an awful QB, I said he’s very average which doesn’t equate to being a franchise QB.

1

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

“very average” is good and you’re acting like it’s bad lmao

1

Anonymous OP 20w

Very average doesn’t win you meaningful games anymore unless the owner is willing to spend a lot of money and the GM knows how to construct a super team. I find Shedeur to be similar to Teddy Bridgewater and even if he didn’t have all those injuries he wasn’t ever going to do anything crazy.

1

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

Nah, you’re looking at a Tua level QB. Accurate, poised, limited for sure, but he is going to be an NFL starter for awhile.

1

Anonymous OP 20w

I don’t think highly of Tua either and think the Dolphins are better off replacing him. Tua has a weak arm, limited in play creation and lacks at extending plays, and completely shits the bed Derek Carr style when pressured.

1

Anonymous OP 20w

Also someone can be an average QB and a starter for a long time while also never achieving much.

1

Anonymous mr.orangutan 20w

Don’t disagree. I have an issue with people acting like he doesn’t belong in the league.

1

Anonymous OP 20w

That’s fair

1

Anonymous #1 20w

That guy also says Shedeur is balling

1