NFL on Sidechat | Debating top 5 QBs is like trying to make a mount Rushmore of major American cities. New York la and Chicago are nonnegotiable and then you get to the final spot and like 5 niggas have a solid argument

Sidechat

Download

Join communities on Sidechat Download

NFL 2w

Debating top 5 QBs is like trying to make a mount Rushmore of major American cities. New York la and Chicago are nonnegotiable and then you get to the final spot and like 5 niggas have a solid argument

🦧

Anonymous 2w

Nah, I’d say that’s more for the 6-10 spots. Mahomes, Allen, Lamar, Burrow, and Herbert shouldn’t even be debatable at this point.

🐻

Anonymous 2w

This year is fun because you can make cases for guys like Stafford, Dak, Baker, Darnold, and Maye. That said we know the actual top 5 is Mahomes, Burrow, Allen, Jackson, and Herbert.

Anonymous

mr.orangutan 2w

Herbert has thrown 7 interceptions this year and we’re only halfway through he’s one of the guys that definitely ISNT in the 5 spot. 2-1 td/int ratio with Ladd mcconkey, not so washed anymore Keenan Allen, and breaking out Quentin Johnston, and a solid ass tight end, and a stud rb to back it up is not top 5 qb material

-3

Anonymous

OP 2w

I was a bit off on the td-int it’s like 16-7 but that’s still straight up not good, especially after how protective he was of the football last year with far worse weapons

-3

🦧

Anonymous

OP 2w

…you’re a box score watcher

Anonymous

mr.orangutan 2w

Box score is easiest to bring up in arguments, but I have the displeasure of living in California at the moment (only school that gave me a full ride) and I’ve watched every chargers game. He has not been a top 5 qb this season. Baker and Stafford at the very least have easily been better, especially Stafford. Herbert has been disgustingly reckless and he would’ve needed at least 20 tds by now to make up for it

-2

Anonymous

beardownsyndrome 2w

“Herbert”