
Jordan throws significantly longer passes on average tho. And the Packers lead the league in drops by a wide margin. So I wouldn’t take completion percentage to be a deciding factor. And Caleb has thrown less picks because he played half as many games. Again I think they’re both great and both top 10 in the league. I’d just take Love cuz he makes some ridiculous throws (not that Caleb can’t also, just haven’t seen as many from him yet)
Now I know damn well you were watching that playoff game last season when Caleb made MULTIPLE ridiculous throws 😭😭 I would say that he hasn’t thrown as many so far this season because he hasn’t needed to, our offense is relatively consistent and reliable so there’s not been a need for Hail Mary passes. I think that Jordan is not in the bottom 10 quarterbacks in the league, but he’s also not in the top 10. There are many other quarterbacks that have better stats than Love, Caleb included.
There are 3 quarterbacks in the league with 50+ TDs and 15 ints or less, and 2 of them are unanimously agreed to be great quarterbacks (Lamar Jackson and Patrick Mahomes). The other one is Caleb Williams. I personally believe that he’s considered controversial because he’s unconventional and people have an issue with that, but he’s been extraordinary in the few years he’s spent in the league.