
i can get on board with this sentiment more than the original post, tbh. that just kind of felt like gatekeeping symptoms that may be uncomfortable but not pervasive enough for a formal diagnosis. it also seemed to generalize neurotypical people the way neurodivergent people are often upset about being generalized. idk. i just got bad vibes from it, could be a me problem.
My family ignored my mom’s narcissism and toxic/control freak personality when I grew up cause they automatically assumed it was undiagnosed autism cause we had a history of it (my family means well they just have little-to-no knowledge on neurodivergence). She seems 100% neurotypical. My family had a history of adhd/autism we didn’t know about til I was very young, im the only one that was officially diagnosed.
Yes these are medical conditions and don’t deserve to be stigmatized. But narcissism and psychopath, for example, are terms that relate to conditions which inherently affect the people surrounding the sufferer. So I understand why narcissist and psychopath are used negatively. Because people with those conditions can severely hurt other people. So while I wouldn’t call them ‘personal flaws’, no medical condition is a flaw. I would absolutely see why people use those terms negatively.
The problem is when people refer to someone as these as an insult, or are basically armchair diagnosing someone. A condition that might negatively affect people around you doesn’t give anyone an excuse to use that condition as a descriptor for a bad person. Extreme cases of autism also have the capacity to harm others, but it’s still not okay to use autistic as a negative descriptor.
True, but also, these words have multiple meanings. Narcissistic can refer to someone who actually suffers from narcissism, or it can refer to someone who is very self-centered, synonymous with egotistical. Psychopath, likewise, is used as a catch-all term to mean insane, crazy, etc. I’m not arguing for or against these usages. But I think it’s important to note that our language does this. We do the same thing with tons of medical conditions.
For example, people say things like ‘Could you speak up, I’m kind of deaf’ or ‘How did I not nice that right in front of me? I’m actually blind’ Insane is another great example. When you call someone insane, you’re not usually saying they’re clinically insane. You’re saying they’re acting ridiculous or unreasonable or so forth.