
No. So basically what happened is before me they had only been in polyamory’s/open relationship. We’ve been together for almost two years now and it’s really starting to eat on their mental health. They spent their whole life unlearning religion and heteronoarmatiy and stuff like that. They’ve really been trying here for monogamy to work. But, now they are starting to feel a lot of self hatred for just having normal thoughts (I.e that persons hot), I told them because they have been trying
I was always open until my last relationship. I had a very religious upbringing and went through the unlearning process. I have never needed to by open for my mental health but my ex used it as an excuse to cheat. They were just looking for external validation because they couldn’t self regulate. It sounds like this is uncomfortable for you and not what you want for the relationship. They got into it knowing you’re monogamous. This feels manipulative and deeply unhealthy on their part.
That’s a pretty odd solution imo, you can reassure them that you don’t mind them thinking about others without completely opening the relationship. If you’re not comfortable with them doing things with someone else, make that clear. Their guilt is not a reason to just remove that boundary, though of course you should help them work through it and hopefully grow closer in the process