
It’s basic human psychology to assume things about someone as our brain tries to efficiently zone them into boxes shaped by our experiences and opinions. It’s normal, and typically completely harmless. It’s a fair assumption to think the person wearing a frilly dress, pink hair, full makeup, AFAB walking out of the all girls dorm would use she/her pronouns. Its harmful when you treat them differently, insult them, think less of them, and refuse to adopt their preferred pronoun use when corrected
i agree with you that it WOULD be better, however, as an american it is hard to break down the culture that surrounds us which is the fact that we are taught to assume regardless. this is a thing that is ingrained very deeply from a young age, and even as a nonbinary person myself, it is hard for me to battle with the thoughts in my mind when i assume about my own self identity or my friend's identities. it would be better, but that doesn't mean its feasible to happen in the next few years
You can disagree but you’re still wrong. Someone here has already said it’s uncomfortable to be referred to neutrally. There are genuinely people in this world who it does upset to use they/them pronouns with (esp trans people since many get referred to as they/them even after expressing their identities and pronoun preferences as an insult). It’s nice to assume neutrality, but it’s still flawed. There’s genuinely no “perfect”solution, just one that is most kind
It can. If I put a lot of effort into presenting myself a certain way, and have been struggling with self acceptance and feelings of passing, someone using gender neutral pronouns even when trying to be nice and not assume can be super triggering bc you’re still not being perceived the way you’re desperately trying to present as. But like you said, it’s best to ask those things when you first meet someone to avoid that situation all together