
Skimmed the supergirl video: I didnt notice any dogwhistles, his criticisms ranged from “good” to “pretty weak” but he didnt say anything misogynistic that I heard. I think it’s just his tone tbh. He sounds like every generic nostalgia critic knockoff who’s a fascist nut, but at least in this video, he’s just a mediocre reviewer.
The reason I chose “supergirl” is because it would be really easy to be a bigoted prick about this movie, which wasn’t very good (but was better than reviewers give it credit for, what who said that). His criticisms were framed well (which is notable because it’s a defined break from the right-wing critic-sphere). I think he missed some important stuff (regarding her history on earth, which was about 3 years long) but most critics did, so it’s not really a fair critique for me to make.