Anonymous #3 8w

Nobody asked

5

Anonymous #2 8w

Sure, also not the meaning I took away. Even if grandpa was born Jewish, the speaker in the hypothetical isn’t halachically Jewish. So why mention Reform or conversion at all except to imply that conversion and being Reform create greater distance from authenticity.

2

Anonymous OP 8w

Poster is confused by someone commenting on their social media post meant to engage with others!

-3

Anonymous #3 8w

I posted this to point out the importance of being extremely discriminate when it comes to who we call fake Jews. I still think you’re a loser.

3

Anonymous OP 8w

And I still think you’re a loser since you’re aligning yourself with genocide. Congrats on forgetting our entire history - sincerely your fellow neighborhood Jew

-5

Anonymous #3 8w

Still didn’t ask, if you want to masturbate go do it in private.

7

Anonymous OP 8w

OP here, my intention wasn’t to disparage converts or reform jews, merely to illustrate how these people grasp at any connection to Judaism in order to weapon it.

5

I would never call someone a fake Jew based on their opinion about Israel. Whether I called someone a fake Jew or not would hinge on two things: 1) whether they were Jewish, and 2) whether they used the words “as a Jew.”

5

Anonymous OP 8w

Someone tokenizing themselves doesn’t make them not Jewish any more than a gay guy tokenizing himself would suddenly be straight

5

Anonymous #2 8w

Reform Jews who are Jewish by patrilineal descent where there was no conversion are not halakhicly Jews either tho

4

Anonymous #6 8w

Correct, which is why there’s two things there, they’d have to attempt tokenize themselves and also not be Jewish.

0

Anonymous OP 8w

Oooh, I totally misunderstood that, my b, I thought you were saying either of them makes someone a fake jew not the two of them together

1

You’re so close bro

1

Anonymous OP 8w

I didn’t ask you for your opinion either bud, it’s a public forum that’s how it works. Cool false equivalence though

0