Anonymous #2 5w

Well yeah but we are talking about the Jewish American population has a whole not 10% of it

10

Anonymous OP 5w

I mean over 40% of American Jewry identifies as Jewish in name only. Distinctions are important

-1

Anonymous #2 5w

Eh there’s Christians all across the country counting for stats and they probably don’t even celebrate Easter

15

Anonymous #3 5w

But how would someone who is Jewish but admits they hold no Jewish values at all a representative of the “Jewish opinion?”

0

Anonymous #2 5w

Yeah but American Jews who are Reform, Conservative, Nondenominational, and unaffiliated Al aren’t, and voted against Trump in significant numbers

6

Anonymous #2 5w

Someone who is Jewish is Jewish, regardless of whether their values are rooted in our religion (and honestly, from my experience, a lot of “Jews in make only” have been more shaped by Jewish values and history than they think they have) But also even if you ignore that 40% the majority of Jews still voted for Harris

9

Anonymous #2 5w

They’re still jewish?? What

5

Anonymous OP 5w

I never said otherwise and that’s not my point

1

Anonymous #2 5w

The orthodoxy even is more split than you may think. I grew up in a very modern orthodox environment where everyone had democrat signs in their yard and that’s in Atlanta GA

0

Anonymous #2 5w

Then what was I point I don’t understand

1