Anonymous #2 1d

I’ll raise you one higher, how many are actually Jewish and how many have been convinced that they are Jewish by Neo-reconstructionist bullshit?

10

Anonymous #2 1d

Just bc they don’t believe in god doesn’t mean they’re not Jewish. Are you fr

2

Comment Deleted

0

The way yall are starting to sound like Christian’s is scary

0

Anonymous #4 1d

I didn't say it made them not Jewish. I only said it made them a bad representation of Jewish values

5

Comment Deleted

0

Anonymous #2 1d

Define Jewish values

0

Shitting on other Jews because they don’t represent these so called “Jewish values” makes you sound like a Christian indeed

0

Anonymous #4 1d

The values of the mizvos as taught by Moshe on Har Sinai and expounded by our rabbis, sages, and prophets

4

Anonymous #4 1d

^^ In what world could someone who doesn’t believe in Judaism and is simply JINO reflect what it means to be Jewish. In what world, logically, does that make any sense

5

Anonymous #5 1d

And all of those things are perceived differently from different people. So again, be more specific on your “Jewish values”

-1

Anonymous #2 1d

Bc they’re still Jews and they’re are still as valid as Jews who believe in god

-1

Anonymous #4 1d

There are 613 core Jewish values, I’m not going into all of them for some schmuck on the Internet

11

Anonymous #5 1d

Yeah and all of them are perceived differently by everyone. Isn’t that like our whole philosophy

0

Anonymous #4 1d

You’re arguing with a ghost lol. They’re valid as Jews, sure. But they’re not valid in representing what it means to be Jewish if they themselves don’t believe in it lol. Think about it for one second

5

Anonymous #4 1d

So close, but perception doesn’t change the value; the values are well established by the teachings of Mishna and gemara

3

Comment Deleted

0

She but thanks

1

Anonymous #2 1d

He is strawman-maxxing

4

Anonymous #2 1d

I’m having a really hard time caring honestly. You guys are just making it worse and I really don’t give a fuck now

0

Anonymous #3 1d

She but thanks

6

Anonymous #4 1d

Yes, they Jews who believe in Judaism having a problem with their religion being co-opted for political gain are the ones making it worse, not the ones that spend their days trying to tell the world that communism is Jewish. Right

8

Anonymous #2 1d

Straw man maxxing I never said communism is Jewish ☠️ I don’t think anyone here said that

1

Anonymous #4 1d

Multiple people here have argued that

1

Anonymous #5 1d

Not me

1

Anonymous #4 1d

Communism is Jewish who do you think was on the front lines against the Nazis?

8

Anonymous #1 1d

Literally! They want us to forget our history

5

Anonymous #1 1d

I never claimed it was or wasn’t I was being accused of saying it was when I didnt say anything like that

5

Anonymous #2 1d

It’s way more in line with Jewish values to be on the left vs the right, what are you even talking about. You don’t even know our history

1

Anonymous OP 23h

Reducing Judaism to a plot on the American political spectrum is gross

0

Anonymous #2 23h

…is that not exactly what you’re doing?

3

Anonymous OP 23h

Quite literally no. Idk how you take “people who do not believe in Judaism are most likely not the best representatives of Judaism” and think it means anything other than those words

-1

Anonymous #2 23h

You’re assuming they don’t believe in Judaism bc they’re on the left tho like what the actual fuck lmao

5

Anonymous OP 23h

Right omg💀

3

Anonymous OP 23h

I guarantee you that 99.9% of Marxist Jews going to Marxist reading clubs are not observant. Like such an overwhelming majority it’s not even a generalization anymore. Marxism itself is literally anti religion

-1

Anonymous #2 23h

So what if they’re not. Why does it matter

1

Anonymous #2 23h

Well you are dead wrong dude idk what to tell you. Get out of your right wing bubble. I live in a red state too btw. Normal, compassionate Jews are out there, believe it or not

3

Anonymous #2 23h

It’s not anti religion at all either btw

4

Anonymous OP 23h

Compassionate Jew =\= observant Jew. Eating pork is not a Jewish value just because there are nice Jews that eat it. Marx literally says religion is a man made coping mechanism and will cease to exist when the communist utopia is established. It’s by definition anti religion. And I’m not gonna argue Marxist theory, but it’s common sense that the only people who represent Jewry are those who practice and believe in Judaism. Those who don’t represent us are still Jews

4

Anonymous #2 23h

Marx was the furthest thing from believing in utopias, it’s literally called scientific socialism. He simply recognized the role of religion in society: “Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.” That’s speaking positively about religion. Not negatively Being a good person will always supersede dietary guidelines, sorry.

0

Anonymous OP 23h

Calling something an opium you’re trying to take man off of is not positive 💀 And thank you for proving my point. You’re free to have that opinion, but that’s not the Jewish opinion

1

Anonymous #6 16h

This is just not true whatsoever 😭

0

Anonymous #6 16h

And no offense but this reminds me of the “Jewish” campus protestors who staged a Seder and got the Seder plate wrong and ignored “next year in Jerusalem” lol

1

Anonymous #6 16h

The majority of Jews in the U.S. even young ones are not chronically online sooooo

1

Anonymous #6 16h

That’s not what “next year in Jerusalem” means tho

1

Anonymous #6 16h

Leftist Jews aren’t the chronically online ones, it’s the rabid bigoted racist ones

1

Anonymous OP 16h

I’d say both are

1

Anonymous #6 16h

Yalls hatred of leftists and socialism is really weird, aligns with the biggest fascists throughout history and yall need therapy

1

Anonymous OP 16h

lol I’m liberal. I don’t believe in socialism and think communism should only be a thought experiment but no hatred. But like plenty of Jews were longtime socialists in the 20th century. Actually Israel was quasi socialist for its first few decades but sadly the kibbutzim are the only part left

1

Anonymous #6 16h

Well duh you’re a liberal, that’s what liberals do. You know the saying. Scratch a liberal and a fascist bleeds. You’d pick fascism over socialism. And good thing socialism is more than just a thought experiment. This isnt the 19th century And yeah that’s my point. We’ve abandoned our history and values

1

Anonymous OP 8h

Ah yes, our deep rich history in leftist politics dating back to the wee times of the… 19th century. The guy that’s complaining about abandoning our values here literally said “Being a good person will always supersede dietary guidelines.” Lol. Let’s ignore the rest of the thousands of years of actual Jewish history because…? You don’t care for it?

1

Anonymous #2 5h

If you wanna live like a shtetl Jew in 2026 by all means go for it

1