
Thatās cause when they say ājust come legally,ā they really mean donāt come at all because they have this imagination that immigrants are stealing from their pockets. They know itās damn near impossible to ādo it the right way,ā and they donāt care. Theyāre full of shit but wonāt admit it
No other countries allow illegal immigrants? Iām not sure why we should? Thatās why we are the best country in the world. And some countries going into their country illegally is even punishable by death. And why would the US not want to collect money on people trying to get their visas? That makes way more sense than letting them in for free.
This! And no one is talking about how billions tax dollars a year go to people who are here illegally, towards their health care and education, which yes, I do believe everyone (this includes illegal immigrants deserve an education and healthcare) but why are we acting like this isnāt a huge problem? We have so much going on just on US land alone, this is not the time to be letting everyone in
Are you r*tarded? BILLIONS of dollars are paid out yearly for Medicaid. Consider SNAP, āemergencyā housing, etc too- for illegals alone. Emergency housing is placing these individuals in motels, where taxpayers pay 800/week per person. Obviously-there is a housing crisis, for OUR ppl too.Simple logic deducts itās not a HUMANITY problem itās a RESOURCE problem. I make $23 an hour and work full time and I canāt even afford health insurance. Itās making the choice, doom us all- or limit resources.
Letās stop attacking peopleās character for WAKING UP and seeing it isnāt SUSTAINABLE to take care of new populations pouring in, when the people who are CITIZENS cannot survive- much less take care of the next person. Grow the f*ck up and realize it isnāt realistic. I was a social worker and I can promise you the media deflects how bad this issue is. Left AND right come together in this corruption. Stop feeding into it. Look around, theyāre leading us into a dystopian future.
Again, undocumented migrants are ineligible for government assistance which includes numerous examples youāve described: https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R47318 I would urge you to do more research rather than parrot misinformation that falsely bastardizes a population that pays their taxes without receiving the benefits of it personally.
Also, increase in health insurance cost premiums are partly due to the elimination of government programs such as Medicaid and Medicare for US CITIZENS; with the absence of these programs acting as competition, insurance companies jack up prices since the market is a lot more skewed in their favor: https://publichealth.jhu.edu/2025/whats-behind-rising-health-insurance-costs How about you look up at billionaires and make them pay their fair share so that we can afford cheaper healthcare.
Hey babe? Do something for me. Google how much money is paid out in public assistance to undocumented immigrants. Iāll save you the time, 182 billion. 150 billion when you subtract the contribution of illegals. Again, I worked with these populations as a career. Iām very well aware, by real experience. Not false sources. Funny how you canāt include a source that proves this āineligibilityā.
Not sure why you would rather be ārightā than understand the policies and procedures of the country you live in. There is a separation of federal and state jurisdiction. State funding and local programs are the source, the same way marijuana is legal in NY and illegal federally. How about you research that babe?
You did a great job at proving my point. LEGAL and CONTRIBUTING members of society are being held to a higher financial standard for our NEEDS because of the large disparity in accessible resources. Yall want to save immigrants at your own expense. They wouldnāt do the same for you.
Ok than can you give me instances of state level programs given to undocumented immigrants. And even then, can you justify why they shouldnāt receive said benefits if they to pay they again, do pay taxes: https://taxpolicycenter.org/fiscal-facts/yes-undocumented-immigrants-pay-taxes-and-receive-few-tax-benefits
Again, safety net programs are often accessible to undocumented immigrants. If it were accessible, yes I would gladly pay my taxes if it ment families could eat or not be forced into bankruptcy due to medical costs, these people are humans at the end of the day. I donāt care if they would or would not do the same for me, helping others is not about prizes.
Again, Iām not arguing over the HUMANE thing to do. Weāre talking about the RIGHT thing. Unfortunately, we do not have the resources. We cannot continue supporting the THOUSANDS of new populations pouring in daily. Itās killing our economy, and creating a wealth disparity that isnāt sustainable. Iām with you, f*ck the 1% elitist. But youāre arguing for them if you support what is currently happening.
Everyone says what you THINK is the right thing to say. āTheyāre a humanā āitās the MORAL thing to doā. Itās a classic ethics question. Look at the trolley analogy. Do you let nature take its course and kill the 3 people? Or do you think we have the right to take control and change course to kill the 1 person? At the end of the day, the question is CAN we help everyone? We canāt. This savior complex mentality is slowly killing us as people. Iām sorry, Iām not willing to die or live in survival
Iām not attacking immigrants as people. I would love a society where we all have our needs, and our happiness is prioritized. Unfortunately, we arenāt there. We wonāt get there if we keep diving deeper and deeper into national and global debt giving handouts. Our legal system is corrupt, and yall keep letting their white sympathy propaganda make you volunteer your autonomy and true values.
But immigrants arenāt the only population that is using Medi-Cal more than the state expected. Californiaās Medi-Cal population in general ballooned during the COVID-19 pandemic when the federal government temporarily suspended income eligibility checks to keep people insured during the national emergency. Before the pandemic about 13 million people used Medi-Cal. That number peaked at 15.6 million in 2023 The Legislative Analystās Office has also noted a 40% growth over the last four years in
Again, California is one of 6 states that provide state funding for non-emergency healthcare (and other public assistance programs). Not to mention non governmental agencies and community supports. It mentions this in the article, you must have missed it. All I am saying is it sounds nice to help everyone. But it isnāt realistic. They are drying up our resources. Iāve seen pregnant women homeless on the streets, and other horrors. It all bleeds together.
First of all I am not white, I am black, second of all my father fought for the citizenship of his parents and himself by joining the army. My sympathy is not in āwhite apologeticsā itās in experience with those close to me, third of all, I agree the system is corrupt, so we should look to the billionaires not paying their share and politicians not reforming the system rather than down at migrants looking for a better life.
Itās destructive financially, and difficult to bounce back from. Our veterans, our disabled, OURS IN NEED- are not being helped because the MASS URGENCY of illegal immigrants. Itās a controversial subject and for some reason it takes precedent to people like you. We have no business helping anyone when we canāt help our own people.
No, I did see that portion, however I, I would also like to restablish these people still pay taxes, I donāt see anything wrong with them accessing the few assistance programs they have access to. Additionally I agree that pregnant women on the streets are a horrible thing but we should also not set this up as a trolly problem, there are other methods to get the required funding for both issues.
Again, from experience the VA has been broken for a long time, immigrants have nothing to do with that. And again, I urge you to not look down at migrants who are looking for a better life but UP at politicians being payed by lobbyist and billionaires shilling out EVERYONE to become richer and hoard their wealth.
It is a trolley issue though⦠you arenāt internalizing what youāre reading. We are in TRILLIONS of dollars of debt. Itās about making informed decisions. Our programs cannot sustain the large percentage of people utilizing them. Hence why I say it you cannot provide a service if it cannot be paid for. The 1% has their hand in these policies bc they profit off the corruption. Thatās why Iām arguing if you believe that, supporting immigrants is hypocritical to your values.
We are actively neglecting the people who have needs not met by providing for people we arenāt technically responsible for⦠hence why I say we canāt just act in alignment with what SOUNDS right. You act in order of necessity and priority. I donāt understand why you donāt see how funding is limited- if they receive a certain amount that takes away from what is accessible to LEGAL struggling CITIZENS.
Medicaid alone was $614 billion annually https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R42640/R42640.13.pdf Medi-cal was $8.5 billion annually https://calmatters.org/health/2025/03/medi-cal-budget-shortfall/ Agian, we are not spending as much as you think on undocumented migrants. And again, we would have more cash flow if we challenged politicians to make billionaires pay their share, we all want welfare programs for those in need but kicking people off should not be the only solution
Iām done arguing. Youāre clearly missing the IQ points to understand the larger picture here. Regardless of the specific amount, illegals do not deserve ANYTHING in my mind when CITIZENS are being neglected. Youāre caught in the corruption to the point you canāt see politicians ARE THE BILLIONAIRES. They are paid off to make them more money! The illegals debate is only one of many ways they keep us distracted from our NEEDS AND VALUES, and standing up for them. Be the āheroā in ur mind queen.idc
Which i proved they are mostly ineligible for FEDERAL assistances. My retort was that we needed to stop the problem at the roots rather than cutting off branches to relieve symptoms. And I did not state complexity I stated how the cost difference for welfare used by CITIZENS far out weighed the cost for the few assistance programs on a state level for undocumented immigrants. Please represent the conversation correctly.