Hookup Horror Stories on Sidechat | I hooked up with him in ‘22 because I had a crush on him in hs. He said he wanted to use a butt plug on himself, and I was like “okay, sure, why not?” Bro didn’t bring a plug or prep and got shit all over my plug, and just left. He still asks how it went.

Join communities on Sidechat Download

Hookup Horror Stories 21w

I hooked up with him in ‘22 because I had a crush on him in hs. He said he wanted to use a butt plug on himself, and I was like “okay, sure, why not?” Bro didn’t bring a plug or prep and got shit all over my plug, and just left. He still asks how it went.

6

173

Anonymous 21w

He probably had shit all over his and didn’t want you to see

53

Anonymous 21w

eugh i’m sorry, did you still have a crush on him after that

1

Anonymous

#1 21w

You know I honestly wouldn’t be surprised. The fact that he STILL asks how it went 4 YEARS LATER like bro I had to throw away a $40 sex toy because of you

33

Deleted 21w

Comment Deleted

0

Anonymous 21w

I was NOT about to touch that, you didn’t see how bad it was 🤢

15

Anonymous

#3 21w

Ummm no.

7

Anonymous

OP 21w

LOL

1