Anonymous #5 12w

disrespectfully, you’re still incorrect and disrespectfully if you’re “just living” then why tf do you care what someone calls themselves

52

Anonymous #5 12w

Biology is anything but basic.

52

Anonymous #5 12w

“I’m just living” but u care enough to be transphobic… okay

23

Anonymous #6 12w

We are all made in His image ❤️

32

Everyone has to go through their own personal journey. That’s also part of His plan

19

why does cancer exist? why does God give people chronic illnesses? how are we to know

14

Its just weird post. Lying to kids is wild

-10

Anonymous #1 12w

Did that other person block me or delete their replies?

7

Anonymous #8 12w

There are no children here

33

Anonymous virgosgroove 12w

You missed the point

-6

Anonymous #8 12w

What point? You said lying to kids is wild and there are no children here

23

Anonymous virgosgroove 12w

You can still be someone’s kid as an adult. Do you understand basic biology? Clearly not since you uptvote and support this post😭😂

-9

Anonymous #8 12w

You’re being obtuse on person. Nobody can infer that you meant a grown adult when you say “children”. Pls be serious

22

Anonymous virgosgroove 12w

Im so offended

-8

Anonymous virgosgroove 12w

Probably deleted their replies, since they’re not showing up on my end, either

9

Anonymous virgosgroove 12w

beyhive commenting with love acceptance and celebration? fork found in kitchen i love our community

6

Anonymous #1 12w

guys this isn’t an argument or a pissing contest, that’s just how i feel and you can feel how you feel and that’s cool✊🏻

-1

Anonymous #9 12w

So fun fact age and race aren’t the same thing as gender nor is gender even the same thing as sex. Why don’t we wait for the studies to come out saying that people can be born with brains of a different race or get dysphoria because they know they’re supposed to be a different age.

26

Anonymous #12 12w

We need to make politics boring and mental asylums great again for the left😭yalls new world ideology is insane. Democrats from 90s and before would look at yall funny

-8

Anonymous #8 12w

Yes I should totally be in a mental asylum for *checks notes* believing in the existence of a minority group and supporting their rights. That’s totally American. Definitely not a screeching violation of the 1st Amendment.

7

Anonymous #12 12w

Nobody once said age and race are the same as gender the point was to say time can identify age, testing a human and eyes can identify race. You don’t need studies you need a calendar and human eyes. You need a study to tell you when to be willingly ignorant too? The same can be done with gender. Are you suggesting different races have different brains as well? Seems like the argument a racist would use to justify discrimination.

-3

Anonymous #9 12w

Race actually doesn’t exist, just like gender. If you had reading comprehension, you’d understand that my first comment was literally saying there are no differences in the brains of different races. But there are differences in male and female brains. And brain scans frequently show that trans people have brains more similar to their perceived gender than their sex assigned at birth.

19

Anonymous #6 12w

why’d you have to bring religion into this

2

Anonymous #9 12w

So if they could change their race you would agree that trans women are women?

7

Anonymous #12 12w

I didn’t know that and that does open a new perspective on that for me! Im actually glad I know that now about their brains and did some research on it. I can agree that people can FEEL out of place in their own bodies but I would say that doesn’t change their original sex nor does it change their gender entirely.

1

Anonymous #16 12w

Yeah I mean if you can show me a Asian guy turn black sure I’ll believe anything

8

Anonymous #9 12w

you’re so silly

1

Anonymous #13 12w

The Silliest

3

Anonymous #9 12w

So in the far off future when advances cell therapies or CRISPR derived technologies make it easy for someone to change their genes in away that they present as a different race … is that when you’ll agree trans women are women? Because if so… then your problem is not accepting what current technologies allow ppl to do.

5

Anonymous #16 12w

I mean yeah when you can change someone's phenotype and alter the chromosomes and genome of someone. Then you essentially bio engineered a new person at that point. Your not talking about someone feeling different your talking about gene editing and creating a new person entirely. So I mean yeah when you remove every biological male aspect of someone and replace it with female ones then yeah but again that's what I've been saying that it's all in the biology.

5

Anonymous #9 12w

oh my god sex and gender are not the same thing. tell me an instance of someone genetically modifying themselves to have certain chromosomes to change their sex. gender can be fluid. just shut up

9

Anonymous #13 12w

you’re talking a lot like you know about the topic

7

Anonymous #9 12w

Incorrect. Phenotypes are affected by environment and the interaction with their genes. And the ppl across races don’t have the same genes so again, you’re either 1) baiting, 2) don’t accept the available technologies and what they let ppl do. And throughout history trans ppl were accepted in multiple cultures and varying ways. They could only do what their technologies allowed, but they were present and accepted.

7

Anonymous #13 12w

Okay so your argument is more emotional than anything. All I'm saying is I disagree and that our gender is represented in our sex. And unless you can change the sex then the gender doesn't change.

1

Anonymous #9 12w

and you have no argument. youre not making any sense. gender and biological sex are not the same thing. you just refuse to accept that fact

11

Anonymous #16 12w

#9’s brain would explode learning about two spirit identities in other cultures

11

Anonymous #13 12w

No I agreed with you that they aren't the same thing. I disagreement was that they don't have a correlation

1

Anonymous #9 12w

why say “unless you change sex the gender doesn’t change” if you don’t think they’re the same thing. sex does not align with gender unless that persons identifies with their sex at birth. which is extremely complicated. what do you think about intersex individuals?

10

Anonymous #13 12w

Sure bc native American were the pinnacle of human achievement and we should take our notes from them.

-2

Anonymous #9 12w

yeah you’re baiting. thats wild to say

11

Anonymous #13 12w

we literally colonized them 😭

7

Anonymous #9 12w

and two spirit identities are in other cultures, not just indigenous peoples of the americas. “native american” is outdated

8

Anonymous #9 12w

Native Americans? Well you assumed that's who I meant. But no there are many others. It's mainly abrahamic religions that have the problem. And more importantly... idk... why don't you ask Benjamin Franklin. He had many Native American friends and used some of their ideas to incorporate into the constitution. And finally, 1 appreciate you coming out as a bigot! So proud of you.

9

Anonymous #13 12w

This is 9 now that they got pwned by facts and logic

6

Anonymous #13 12w

Im said the sex and gender would change because you implied the change of someone’s entire identity by altering brain chemistry and entire biology using future technology. And I think intersex people are a fascinating but also a toss up because they carry both male and female biological traits and it’s not always just genitalia that are the issue in that.

5

Anonymous #9 12w

i didn’t imply anything, you’re getting confused. i never said anything changing someone’s entire identity and brain structure. are you okay? i think you need a nap

1

Anonymous #9 12w

and there’s no “issue” when it comes to understanding intersex identities, hope that helps

1

Anonymous #13 12w

Sorry that was #16 telling me to pretend I was using some future tech to completely change someone 😭

3

Anonymous #9 12w

you lack brain cells for this discussion

2

Anonymous #13 12w

There is an issue because they can look male and have a male genitalia while having ovaries. Im sure I would be confused if I was them because I would be stuck with male and female biology

1

Anonymous #13 12w

Intersex comes in many forms

0

Anonymous #9 12w

what exactly do you mean by “male and female biology”. details please

3

What you’re referring to is the amount of melanin someone has in their body. Race is a social construct used to divide and subjugate people based arbitrarily on phenotypes. This is clear when you look at the fact that definitions of race change constantly. Why were Irish people considered colored 150 years ago but white now? And why do Middle Eastern people have to check the white box when filling out the US census? What race is a black albino person?

6

Anonymous #13 12w

a toss up? no, they’re valid

1

Anonymous #9 12w

You outed yourself as a bigot. I’m done wasting my time on your weak bait.

11

Anonymous #1 12w

I took a philosophy of religion class and the main topic we discussed was the argument of pain and suffering. If god is all good all knowing and all powerful, why would these horrible things exist?The biggest excuse argued was free will and that we can’t live in a perfect utopia or that this life doesn’t even matter, it’s the afterlife that matters. Idk to me that’s a bunch of bs. I’d give up my free will any day so a child doesn’t suffer from cancer but to each their own.

5

Anonymous #5 12w

you said “I feel ___ way because of [misconception],” so ofc people are gonna point out how the basis of your feeling is wrong lmao. feel what you want, just realize you’re being irrational.

0

Anonymous #15 12w

sex is bimodal, not binary. and this is about gender lmao, not sex

16

Anonymous #8 12w

mfw when I have literally nothing to say so I just red herring my way through the conversation:

1

Anonymous #8 12w

if you wanna say why you think it’s lying, go ahead. if not, then you’re just admitting your opinion is so fragile that it’ll shatter the moment it’s said lmao

1

Anonymous #17 12w

Idk but when I was an atheist I had a very pessimistic nihilistic view. Like if God doesn’t exist and there is no life then what’s the point of living anyway. Happiness and suffering are just chemical reactions so it’s not real anyway y fight so hard to stay alive if I’ve been sad for so long

5

Anonymous #5 12w

As a biologist, you’re so fucking incorrect shut the fuck up.

14

Anonymous #15 12w

No one’s discussing changing sex. We’re discussing gender, which is a made up construct

20

Anonymous #8 12w

Do you understand advanced biology?? Do you trust everything you’re told in third grade? Is this you?? https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=VucczIg98Gw&ra=m

5

Anonymous #8 12w

“Make mental asylum‘s great again“ you know people were tortured, abused, neglected, and killed in those places? They literally used to put mentally ill people in fucking cages. You’re either completely uneducated or you know this and you just want people to get tortured

7

Anonymous #3 12w

The asylum near me had almost no staff and patients were sitting in their own filth in hallways because there was no rooms. People were abused and starved and beaten and neglected.

6

Anonymous #21 12w

My grandmother worked at one, it’s abandoned now, but growing up me and my dad always went there to explore the abandoned buildings. I’ll never forget the time I was looking for an entrance through a window in the basement, and I saw a bunch of cages. And I mean, PILES of cages. Here’s a pic of one I took years ago. To think they used to put humans in these is disgusting.

8

Anonymous #3 12w

Jesus that horrific

8

Anonymous #21 12w

I hope #8 sees this and rethinks their “make mental asylum’s great again” comment.

6

Anonymous #20 12w

Respectfully, I don’t think you understood what 15 said at all.

0