
Go to Brasil and watch them clear pristine rainforest more biodiverse than any suburban data centre plot, killing uncounted numbers of native animals and trees, to establish monoculture beef or beef feed farms. We living in America are insulated from the impacts of the meat industry and only fight the AI industry because it is affecting our own backyards. It is like marijuana vs heroin. Both are bad and should be stopped. But one is worse
Meat causes more harm to sentient beings, yes. Yes, it is inherently unethical. Perhaps it is more environmentally destructive than AI: I think that’s probably pretty hard to quantify. But if your response to “AI is bad” is “beef is worse” then YOU ARE DOING AI APOLOGETICS. You can absolutely criticize both, but if your response criticism of one is to do a “whataboutism,” then YOU ARE NOT CRITICIZING THE BEEF INDUSTRY. You’re EXCUSING the AI industry.
That is not an excuse…it is like if what Russia is doing to Ukraine is bad then what Israel has been doing doing to Palestine is worse. Both are bad and should be stopped and I hate both. Am I being apologetic to Russia for saying what Israel is doing to Palestine is worse??? No that is not logical
That’s fucking stupid. If your response to “I don’t think Russia should invade Ukraine” is “erm actually, Israel shouldn’t be doing a genocide in Palestine” then congratulations! You’re doing Russian propaganda! Both statements are true. But the second is NOT RELEVANT TO THE FIRST IN ANY WAY. You are deflecting from the issue by bringing up a DIFFERENT ISSUE. That’s the dictionary fucking definition of whataboutism.
I am not pro ai, and I know I’m not discussing this topic with a group of vegans. I am saying that by logic, anyone in this community who goes out of their way to avoid AI and denounce its presence unwanted in our lives, as we should, should also be attempting to fight meat consumption with the same energy.
I am disagreeing with the fact that the environmental movement has shifted towards combating AI. Which is still GOOD. But in doing so it has eclipsed the problem of the meat industry which you agree is more destructive and has been historically more oppressive, particularly in global south countries that send meat products to America. You are directly impacted by the problem of AI but you are not directly impacted by the beef industry.
Fucking stop. This is pathetic. As I’ve explained quite clearly, THIS IS NOT RELEVANT. AI is the topic at hand, if you want to talk about the meat industry, make your own goddamn post. I have not eaten beef in like, 7 years at this point. This criticism isn’t coming at you from some guy who just wants to eat burgers, it’s coming at you from a guy who agrees that the meat industry (beef in particular) is bad, and who knows how rhetoric works.
There is a difference between whataboutism and moral activism. I will go to the environmental protest against AI with you gladly, but many people who also protest against AI for environmental reasons dismiss the impact of destructive meat industry. Giving up AI is easy, but giving up your al pastor is much more difficult and we should be encouraging this as the next step in environmentalism Plus the techbro culture that gave us AI is rooted in meat maxxing toxic masculinity.
True, a lot of the easily accessible protein substitutes in vegetarian/vegan diets are nut or soy based, which blocks anyone with an allergy to those from the diet. Some people can’t process the proteins in plants and can starve themselves of the nutrients without meat, like my cousin.
the comparison is so stupid. if we compared everything, we would never get anywhere, EVER. “hey assault is bad!” “yeah but murder is worse!” what are we doing. criticizing ppl by bringing other issues into the mix is so counterproductive. AI and the meat industry may have similar flaws are 2 unique issues that need to be handled that way. there is absolutely nothing stopping u from writing your own email or deciding what to make for dinner with the ingredients in your fridge on your own
they also have a lot of differences, including one MAJOR difference: one is easily avoidable, and one is not avoidable for many people. and saying one is worse does not take away from the issue of the other, which is the point of this post. bringing up the meat industry when discussing ai is a red herring fallacy.
nobody said it’s irrelevant, it’s just not relevant to a conversation where people are only talking about ai. nobody says the beef industry isn’t bad or even arguably worse for the environment, but it IS completely irrelevant to the conversation talking about people’s rampant ai usage.