Anonymous #2 15w

How is OP anti-semitic? Every human rights group, the UN special report, the genocide scholars have all agreed its a genocide

11

Anonymous #3 15w

The ‘story that needs to be passed down to generation to generation’ part reeks of something more sinister. The whole ‘never forget what the 🧃did’ mindset as if they’re the only guilty party in this tragic conflict.

0

Anonymous #2 15w

1. He didnt say “to generation to generation”. You made that up. 2. He never mentioned Jews. He just said “Israel”. You’re just making things up.

10

Anonymous #2 15w

Genocides should be remembered and not forgotten. Also, wdym “as if theyre the only guilty party”. You mean the western nations are also at fault for enabling and helping commit genocide, right?

5

Anonymous #2 15w

“Tragic conflict”. Can you condemn the IDF and say its a genocide?

2

Anonymous #4 15w

OP didnt mention Jewish people. Whats wrong with simply saying Israel should be held accountable for its genocide against Palestinians?

1

Anonymous #3 15w

The word Holocaust is not a universal word. It is specifically in reference to the most atrocious and industrialized genocide the modern world has seen, and specifically against Jewish people. Not all things are a “Holocaust”, and inverting or universalizing it, and ESPECIALLY weaponizing it against Jewish people, is gross

7

Anonymous #4 15w

You do realize Israel is committing the Palestinian Genocide right now?

0

Anonymous #4 15w

And once again, OP never mentioned Jewish people

-1

Anonymous #3 15w

Israel is not going door to door and asking for the ethnic identity of its citizens, sending them to gas chambers, and using them as slaves for its war machine. It is not going to surrounding countries and telling them to turn in Palestinians to be sent to the gas chambers. It is not killing 6 million people. You recognize the difference?

0

Anonymous #4 15w

Israel is starving millions of innocent people in a giant death camp in which they would be shot if they escaped. Civilians are targeted and slaughtered, tortured in various ways. This is all being done because the people inside are the “wrong ethnicity”

1

Anonymous #4 15w

Are you going to condemn the IDF and recognize the genocide in Gaza?

1

Anonymous #3 15w

Yes, it’s genocidal. But that’s not up for debate as you’ve pointed out. What is up for debate is the intent behind those who frequently trumpet “genocide” as if they are an honorable group who is standing up for what’s right, when really their motivations are far more insidious.

-1

Anonymous #2 15w

How is it insidious for OP to simply say he wont forget the victims of the Palestinian Genocide?

3

Anonymous #2 15w

Can you condemn the perpetrators of the genocide, the IDF?

3

Anonymous #3 15w

I condemn the IDF for their actions. Do you condemn Hamas for theirs?

-1

Anonymous #3 15w

It’s not quite so simple though. It’s being used and abused as a basis to harass and attack the Jewish community everywhere, not merely as a basis to criticize Netanyahu or the Israeli government.

-1

Anonymous #2 15w

I’m not going to “both sides” a genocide, or apartheid, or occupation, esp bc I dont trust what the US or Israel says about Hamas

4

Anonymous #2 15w

Literally all OP said was he wouldnt forget the victims of the Palestinian genocide. And you attacked him and accused him of being an anti-semite

6

Anonymous #2 15w

You seem to imply that we should just forget the Palestinian Genocide

0