
Your personal attractive level (which is super arbitrary btw and completely unique to every single person’s perception) doesn’t matter if she isn’t attracted to you. You can’t make someone feel someone feel something for you and I’m sorry it hurts but the way you think you should be able to “talk her into” wanting you says you don’t actually think of her as a person the way you think you do.
Ok I was being nice earlier but apparently that doesn’t work with you. Just from this conversation I can say you aren’t a “clear choice” you’re jealous and possessive over a person that isn’t yours. She fucked strangers who couldn’t hurt her because they weren’t in her life and their opinions didn’t matter. You obviously are in her life and I can’t say whether your opinion matters to her but I can say that I don’t blame her for not choosing you.