
I understand both sides bc ppl have preferences and it can be frustrating that information is being withheld from you, but also plz take into consideration that trans folk are more vulnerable when their identity is on full display, some ppl have fetishes and prey on trans people or will even seek them out just to commit violent acts. It rlly is just a safety thing but I get how it can be blindsiding.
I think it’s absurd to call it “hiding” that they’re trans. Unless someone explicitly says their cis, the person they matched with made the assumption that every person on the app is cis by default. That’s on them, not on the trans person. It’s just not talking about personal details of their life before meeting up, that’s normal, not deception.
it is incredibly unsafe to be openly trans in any internet space. not only because you don’t know the people you’re talking to, but because the US government is actively tracking social and medical accounts and keeping tabs on trans people, stripping rights at every turn. if they waited to tell you, it’s because it’s literally a life and death safety issue for them.
I think it depends on when people are comfortable bringing it up, but in general like first date and stuff someone’s medical history does not need to be advertised if they don’t want to. Like yes it can be important in relationships and should be brought up eventually, but on dating apps or first dates or casual hook ups, it’s a private thing. I find it odd that people think they’re being manipulated, when really it’s just not their business.
why is everyone acting like every person they date is to marry? i feel like that’s the issue with this argument. oh i want kids so it’s necessary i know. who said you were having kids with them…no one is faulting you for not dating trans women, it’s just weird to expect someone to disclose the very thing that can get them killed at any moment. just feel tone deaf. no one is trying to trick you
This is a very interesting take because, both side are kinda in the right, since one person feel betrayed because the other person comes out of something that they weren’t perceived as cause you know the person was probably expecting to talk to a woman and not a trans woman and you gotta feel for the trans person because all they want to do is find love and in this world being trans is very hard because they get a lot of hate for being who they are sooo…idk like there no good answer for this. 😬
It’s quite simple actually, I’m fine being friends with you if you’re trans but I just can’t date you. It causes too many problems. If I meet someone and fall in love with them and want to start a family with them, it’s not okay for them to just then tell me they aren’t a real man and cant have kids. That just isn’t cool. Thats not being transphobic, it’s called having preferences.
I think it’s rude and not ok. I’m not into guys at all weather they look like girls or whatever they should say something. Specially when the convo gets a lil naughty or they ask for naughty pics. I don’t want to talk to guy like that. In my head it’s disgusting and makes me really mad when I find out I’m talking to a friend man
i feel like at the end of the day a trans personal isnt biologically a person of the sex they are trying to be so if the person they are going on a date with is expecting a biological woman or man and they aren’t one like yeah…. i feel like that should be mentioned… If i went out with a guy and then found out they were a trans guy id be pretty annoyed bc yeah i wasn’t expecting that…
I got banned for 12 hours but basically all I’m gonna say is that if a Trans person doesn’t want to put that they are trans in their bio on a dating app that is fine, but you HAVE to tell the person you are talking to romantically sooner rather than later. People have different feelings about the whole phenomenon of transgenderness and not being upfront with someone about that in the name of trying to envoke some silent acceptance of transgenderness.
I think because of what has happened in today’s world, there’s a lot of sensitivity around transgenders. But we need to understand that somebody’s preference is not hatred. Love is going to involve picking and choosing. That’s what the point of dating apps are. To swipe and see who matches your interest. Yes safety is a concern for trans individuals, but you jeopardize it more by keeping it hidden from potential partners because not everyone wants to be with someone who is trans.
trans people and people attracted to trans people need their own app because if being open about being trans puts them in danger and being secretive that they’re trans puts them in danger then they need to go somewhere else away from us normal folk and the people that prey on them, but idc what anyone says not disclosing it after the first conversation is exactly what gets them beat tf up to begin tbh
very good point, however, hiding trans identity, especially in the dating world will breed violence. it is unfortunate that one would have to clarify their identity but I view it to be very similar to if you are dating someone and you can’t have children, or you really don’t want children, it’s something that can make or break a relationship and should be told early on.
I'm saying they aren't safe announcing to EVERYONE on that app that they're trans, not that the entire app is fully of predatory or hateful ppl. Ur insinuating that so much so that they need a whole other app when they don't, they just need to be mindful about the information they're sharing which is the whole point of this conversation
Hey guys actual trans person here. Having our own restrooms absolutely the fuck does not give us our own “safe space.” I’m a bio trans man. The whole part of being a man is that I’m a man. Not some “secret third thing” that needs another restroom. I don’t want my “transness” to be called to light, I just want to piss and shit like every other man in the men’s restroom. Shouldn’t be so hard to understand
mind you they already have apps just for them, it’s a choice if they wanna be on a regular dating app then that’s their choice, wtf is so wrong with giving them options?? i didn’t insinuate anything i literally flat out said it and apps like that exist because people in fact use them to feel safe, as they should
you realize that doctors acknowledge that sex assigned at birth is a guess, right? they literally measure the length of an infant’s genitalia and if it happens to be above a certain length they’re “male” and below that they’re “female.” it’s entirely arbitrary and beholding yourself to it proves you haven’t done any research on it.
no thats something you need to tell someone before the first date. Yeah it sucks a lot of people will probably unmatch with you but why would you want someone who doesnt want to be with the real you anyways? Why hide it at first and try to get them attatched when they might not even swing that way? It just seems sus as fuck
woww. You seem to have some deep rooted hatred in your heart. like seriously, are you okay? they made this choice FOR themself so they could feel more comfortable in their body. the point is their body doesn’t match their mind. They don’t accept their current body, so they change theirs into one they feel most comfortable in it. It isn’t for you, it’s isn’t for others. it’s for themself. please think before spreading negativity as such, it’s a bad look for you. get well soon <3
Should men also disclose their penis sizes and whether or not they’re cut on the first date? Should women disclose their breast sizes and whether or not they have an innie or outie, or a condition like vaginismus on the first date? Just to make sure they’re people you’re sexually compatible with/attracted to
trans people are those who identify with a gender other than the one they were assigned at birth (AGAB). AGAB is determined by doctors looking at the length of your genitals and guessing based on that. it has absolutely nothing to do with chromosomes; in fact, 99% of the US population doesn’t know what chromosomes they have.
U can pull someones genetic data and tell by bone structure, marrow, cell makeup, health history, and genitalia that they are a male or a female. Intersex exist too, but usually they have a dominant chromosome that determines their puberty and which will be more dominant. Not all the time but still.
that’s objectively not how it works for the vast majority of the population since, again, 99% of the population has never been karyotyped. trans people are transitioning away from their AGAB, which, again, is fully separated from chromosomes. you can’t say sex = chromosomes since that implies 99% of the population doesn’t know their own sex.
it’s not even about the love they may or may not find as trans women. trans women face disproportionate levels of violence from men for their identity, so advertising themselves as transgender to the thousands of people using these apps is a danger. she shouldn’t have to display it but she should disclose it to the person she matches with as soon as possible.
Alright this is disingenuous A bungalow is different from a skyscraper, they’re both buildings A red bungalow is different from a blue bungalow, still both buildings. One of the above distinctions matters much more than the other when shopping for a home. You don’t take weighted categories and pretend they’re the same to make your argument.
Height and sexual makeup are not the same, even to you. You are much more likely to go up to a stranger and comment on their height than anything sexual. You would be much angrier if your kid was harassed for their gender or sex, than for their height. Height is readily apparent, gender or sex may not be.
if you’d date someone who said they never wanted sex but wouldn’t date them if you found out they were trans, that’d be transphobic. if you’d date someone who did want sex but not kids/couldnt have kids, but wouldn’t like them if you found out they were a trans person with high-verisimilitude bottom surgery, you’d be transphobic. the only reason that makes sense would be genitals/wanting bio kids, but if neither matters and you wouldn’t date them SOLELY bc theyre trans, you’re outing yourself.
the height thing was the weakest example, but there’s significant, identifiable groups who care more about height than someone being trans. if someone says they can’t have kids, then theres effectively no difference to their partner whether or not they’re cis and sterile or trans with bottom surgery. in cases like that, height will (or should) matter to many more people than something intangible like being trans.
Early on yes, but for me in my relationships, early or not, I always make an effort to mention I want kids in the future, not in five years, but eventually, because when I’m dating someone, I don’t want to give them false ideas about not wanting kids when I do y’know, it’s one of those things I don’t feel the need to hold off on mentioning. Because I’m not talking about having kids with them specifically, but in general, does that make sense?
I dunno man probably the same reason why you wouldn’t be attracted to someone shorter than you are someone that is way taller than you or vise versa. I will say that sexuality is a lot deeper than whether someone I just tall or short but again some people just aren’t comfortable dating trans people. 🤷🏾♀️
Well I personally never really understood the whole reasoning or processes of transitioning from one sex to another and at least for me that lack of understanding would seriously affect how I’d view a potential partner. And depending on where a person is within their transitioning they can be deemed as less attractive for some people. Not trying to be rude just stating the truth. There are people out there who are attracted to trans people, but that just isn’t me.
not understanding it is a valid reason if you’re worried you’re not prepared to have them as a partner, though I do recommend reading an article abt trans people if you can. I used to be like that but fell in love with someone I found out was trans, and learned more abt it out of curiosity + wanting to know if we were truly incompatible or not. also, no one would blame you for not being attracted to certain features. it’s more so about understanding those features aren’t inherent to being trans
I agree with you that in the event that a trans person presents fully as their preferred gender, people that don’t want kids will be attracted to them. But most people, a lot of them on this thread, don’t see it the same way. Not everyone likes silicone breasts or even BBLs, and having those things does affect attraction. It’s partly that most trans men and women have not had bottom surgery, but also that surgery can be off-putting https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9621289/
Bro how? they are literally right… I get you guys are trying to be put on an equal basis as “cisgender” people but if I am attracted to a masculine presenting man with a penis and low and behold the guy I am talking to doesn’t have a penis ima be a little shocked ngl. Sex is really important for someone people…
I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect someone to disclose all their POTENTIAL dealbreakers FIRST thing. Like if my first text on a dating app was “hey so just so you know I’m super messy, scared of intimacy, and I’m rude to waitstaff. Oh also I’m going to say I love you after the first date” that’s not expected of anyone else
Comparison is off - saying you are a girl and hiding you’re trans is INTENTIONALLY misleading and lying. Having a condition or unattractive features when it was never mentioned is UNINTENTIONALLY misleading. The intent is absolutely taken into account when you look for a S/O; it shows respect and truthfulness. If that’s “transphobic” to you, the problem lies with you.
Forcing people to conform to letting trans individuals keep it hidden is inconsiderate for other peoples values. And that’s why phobias get enhanced towards the LGBTQ+ community. Love is love, and i’ve met a lot of ppl who are accepting of mine and other lifestyles, because they’re not being forced to be okay with it. Be respectful.
When you sign up for a dating app, you choose a gender - woman or man. That would be considered to most to be saying they’re cisgender when they’re not. I get you don’t see it that way, but most people don’t see trans women as “women”. That’s a can of worms that I don’t want to open, but it should be known. Not acknowledging that is incredibly facetious
Right, but most people talk about it early on to set a tone for the relationship. There are people out there who keep stuff hidden about themselves to be toxic to who they get with, but I think if you are transgender, it is something that should be said somewhat early in the talking stage if they don’t disclose it anywhere. I’m not saying first date type of thing, but waiting to become OFFICIAL and then stating you’re trans seems insensitive to me because, again, people’s values are different.
I really don’t think this should be a second date conversation, why would someone spend time and money on a date with someone who they’re just not going to be attracted to. It doesn’t have to be right off the bat but people are going to be way more upset if they don’t know before the first date. In fact, I’d say it’s dangerous for the trans person to wait that long bc the other person might have a violent reaction to it
What’s unattractive to you isn’t unattractive to everyone. A lot of women prefer cut or uncut or a certain penis size, so should men be expected to describe their genitals in detail on their dating profiles or on the first date? Wouldn’t it be misleading for a woman to assume an American guy is cut only to find out later he’s not, and therefore not attractive to her?
You don’t want to date trans people because you would find their genitals unattractive and expect them to be open about it so you can avoid the things you don’t like. So why wouldn’t it make sense for everyone to be open about what their genitals look like since not everyone’s into the same kinds of penises or vaginas? If we expect trans people to do it before or on the first date then everyone should
For a lot of people, sex is a very important part of a relationship and bad sex has ruined many, many relationships. I think a lot of the time, people will feel intentionally misled if a trans person is talking to them for let’s say a couple of weeks then they find out after spending a lot of time with them. I think I’d personally be disappointed and like I wasted my time because I’m a cis woman and I just cannot touch another person’s vagina. I also value sex more than most people so it varies
that’s not at all what’s being said, the reading comprehension is lacking severely. this conversation is typically transphobic talking points under the guise of having preference and integrity in dating. like as if any man has ever has integrity when it comes to dating and being forthcoming. just don’t date them and be quiet. the vast majority of ppl on apps are not even trans so what’s the problem 😭😭😭
Bottom surgery exists but a lot of people want to have biological children with the person they fall in love with. Of course infertility exists but that’s not usually something you know right off the bat. And also trans people with bottom surgery are more likely to have problems having penetrative sex
My reading comprehension is just fine thank you. Don’t project your smoothless brain bullshit onto me you cunt. And you know what since we shouldn’t assume that everyone you come across is cisgender I think it’s perfectly logical to assume that people who are looking for love and intimacy are coming from the deepest forms of integrity. Unless you agreeing that there are social norms that we has a society adhere to and being trans is not one of them.
I think it’s more that people often want to know about the things that trans people have or have not changed. Being trans has a lot to do with genitals too, and people care a lot about those. So the likelihood that every trans person has something worth disclosing to other people is high.
there’s so many other dealbreakers where it’s considered normal to not disclose them until after some time, and those aren’t disclosed bc of privacy. trans people deserve privacy but more so deserve safety since it’s dangerous to disclose on their profile. if you care about dealbreakers and not outing trans people then why aren’t you addressing the other ones first?
OH MY GOD I never said you shouldn’t be trans or you shouldn’t exist I just don’t wanna fucking date you! Get a grip. I’m a liberal myself but this is fucking ridiculous. If I don’t want to date a fucking woman does that mean I’m homophobic? Like are you actually fucking kidding me. I get you are a marginalized group. I really do, but someone stabbing you for being trans had no interest in dating YOU anyways.
>If I don’t want to date a fucking woman, does that mean I’m homophobic? Objectively speaking, yes. You’re refusing to connect with someone on the basis of something they can’t help. Also, liberals are not immune to ignorance. You would do well to better yourself and grow more tolerant. There will come a time when such bigotry is met with far more than just harsh criticism
Hey hey now- last time I checked people also align their political and religious beliefs as an inherent part of their identity. Perfectly reasonable comparison. Matter of fact your religious and political identity is influenced by your life experiences which is a part of who you are.
it has a much wider variation for what it means to someone. being trans can be a huge part of someone’s life or have almost no bearing on them. some people are very involved in community while others aren’t. it also has almost no inherent values or rules tied to it like Christianity or being MAGA. so it’s still a strange comparison.
people can convert to other faiths or switch political alignments. no one starts or stops being trans, they simply realize they are/aren’t. that’s the difference between inherent and not inherent. something not inherent can (and often will) matter more to someone than inherent parts of them. most people find their job more central to their identity than if they’re left-/right-handed.
the difference is that advertising yourself as transgender, especially as a transgender women, opens yourself to chasers and malicious individuals who may try to harm you for your gender identity. transgender women face disproportionate violence because of this. if they simply inform those who they match with instead, the other person can either accept or reject instead of being someone who wants to do harm to her.
And I’m not saying they have to put the fact that they’re trans in their profile, but once you’ve had a conversation or two and see that the person may be interested in pursuing something, just say “hey I just wanted to let you know that I am trans, is that something you are comfortable with?”
and no this isn’t transphobic before ur dumbass tries to call me that. trans people and cis people are different. someone who is transitioning is actively changing their identity and in some cases, paying to change their biology as well (genital reformation and hormone blockers). a cis person is just someone who identifies with the sex they were assigned to at birth and has all of their biological parts intact
The OG said that it’s not cool to not say you’re trans after you’ve already talked for a while…. Clearly it happens and that’s what I’m commenting on. If you’re trans and we match on an app and we have a convo and then you let me know you’re trans imma be like cool, personally I wouldn’t date you because I’m not into that but we can be friends and I wish you the best
They said it wasn’t mentioned until later in the conversation meaning they JUST started talking so no that doesn’t happen. Nowhere did they say they had been talking “for a while” because no trans person is waiting weeks to months to tell a potential partner they’re trans. The idea that it happens at all is just transphobic propaganda spread online
do you genuinely believe that doctors karyotype every baby to determine their chromosomes for assigned sex? I’ve said it multiple times but they measure the length of your natal genitalia and assign make if longer than a certain amount and female of shorter. they acknowledge it’s a guess and that it’s entirely separated from chromosomes and karyotypes. I’m glad I’m the one in the medical field and not you if you refuse to do anything other than assume you’re right💀
And I never said that they wait months before saying the truth. I simply said that once you guys have had a couple conversations and you know that the other person is interested in pursuing more, that then you need to tell them and make sure they are comfortable with it. I’m not spreading transphobic propaganda. I was just saying that if someone was interested in more then you need to tell them the truth
While there are a some cases of people being born intersex or with strange chromosome combinations, the vast vast majority of people have chromosomes that match with the genitalia they were born with. And that is a perfectly good way to determine chromosomes because there are very few exceptions. And hunny I’m in the medical field and so is my whole family. We actually know what we are talking about though
It’s been said somewhere else here too but there’s at least 5 primary sex identifiers. We do not assign sex based on chromosomes and the vast majority of people don’t know their chromosomes. Trans people going through hrt and srs are “biologically” more in line with what they’re transitioning to than what they’re transitioning from. Hormones and presentation are our largest sex determinants. If you want to classify sex with chromosomes you need to accept dozens of different sexes
if you’re in the medical field then you should realize how dangerous it is to assume traits about your patients without confirmation. which is quite literally what you’re doing. you said you KNOW your chromosomes when you DON’T. and, since you clearly don’t know, the general medical criteria for “intersex” has to do with identifiable physical/developmental traits, not chromosomes. there’s asymptomatic people with alternate chromosomes who live their whole lives and never know.
If you’re falling in love with and trying to start a family with someone within a few conversations then that’s your problem not trans people’s. Again nobody is getting far enough to fall in love with and trying to start a family with someone without disclosing that they’re trans
oh, didn’t see your last comment lol. sex (male/female/intersex) is bimodal and has physical/developmental indicators. most people consider sex assigned at birth (ASAB) to be someone’s sex. on the other hand, gender (man/woman/non-binary for most western societies) is a social construct and varies wildly from culture to culture—dozens of which have had rich histories with three or more genders. it is used in social situations, and you perceive it through someone’s looks & presentation.
*this is a VERY boiled-down and oversimplified explanation of a highly-nuanced topic. if you genuinely want to know more rather than arguing based on your preconceptions, I recommend looking into bimodal sex & gender as a construct. I doubt that will happen but wouldn’t mind a pleasant surprise.
Then maybe you should disclose your preference and that sex is very important to you. I just don’t think the other person should have to predict your personal desires. You talking to a person for a while and being ultimately disappointed by the sex can happen regardless of whether they’re trans, and bottom surgery is also a thing that exists.
cmon people CAN have preferences… but honestly, sure. If I were looking for an asexual relationship and the person fits my personality, values, chemistry, and attractiveness criteria so well that I’ve never clocked them after multiple dates, and checks all the other boxes too… I guess we’re getting married.
Or to prove some point that “being transgender is not a big deal or shouldn’t be a big deal” is stupid. Again, we are talking about someone you are planing to be romantically involved with here. I’m NOT saying you have to go up to strangers and say “Hi my name is so and so and I am trans!” I am not saying that but what I am saying is that if you are talking to someone romantically and you are trans, they should know. Period end of discussion.
Yeah we know gender is a social construct gang we are not stupid, but that social construct is used to help identify whether someone is male or female. No? Unless you want to start pulling everyone fucking pants down to look at their genitalia since you want to eradicate the whole idea and structure of gender. (Fine by me). I appreciate your enthusiasm for wanting to question social normalcy and fight the system. I really do, it show signs of high intellect, but children are dying Kim.
trans people die from targeted hate crimes, and telling strangers they’re trans too early can put them at unnecessary risk. trans people are dying, Kim. this is an important discussion. also, the comment you’re referencing was a direct response to someone’s question. educating p theres on this topic is part of how we stop ignorance and hate for minorities. if you believe there’s better topics for discussion, then you can move on and make a different post about them.
I’ve disclosed it to the point I even have how long I’ve been on HRT and surgery status on my profile. I still do, but I feel like the safest bet is to disclose in DMs. I’ve dealt w trans chasers, a man who tried to lock me in his basement, a hook up that didn’t read my profile and kicked me out while I still had her juices on my face, like there’s no break. I can’t tell if their enthusiasm after reading my profile is for just sex, a fetish, or imminent danger. 🤷♂️