
Hi OP, education became a boondoggle where bureaucracy uses it as a slush fund and assist politicians with their political narratives. I mean in big cities it’s a vicious cycle. Kids don’t learn later to join gangs and later to go to jail. Mayors, police chiefs, and school boards know of this and stop it by actually teaching the kids.
So when a student shows up to class on day 1 with elementary level handwriting, can’t write a complete sentence, and can’t do any math without a calculator, that’s my fault personally? Their years of being pushed to the next grade level despite getting 0 questions right on the state tests, that’s my fault and I just need to “do better”?
One of the classes I teach is Geometry. The year before Geometry, they take Algebra 1. Of my 90 Geometry students, only 17 passed the Algebra 1 state test. Am I meant to reteach the entirety of Algebra 1? When would they learn the standards for the class they’re actually in? This is years and years of academic failure. It is not possible for me to fix all of that in the 40 minutes I have them each day while also doing my actual job of teaching them geometry.
It’s especially tough with math because each year, they build off the stuff they learned in the previous year. So when they fail a math class and are moved on to the next one, it’s inevitable that they’ll fail that one too. The idea behind pushing people along even when they fail is to prevent destroying their motivation and keeping them from just dropping out because they’re too behind. I’m not sure what the proper solution is, but whatever we’re doing now is not working.