1. They earned their way in
2. They won an automatic qualifier
3. The idea that G5 schools should be omitted from any big games is lame
4. The elitism of pure P4 playoffs is a boring idea and ruins the magic of college football
If people care this much about the “highest quality” of matches, go watch the NFL because that’s never what this sport will be
19
Anonymous1w
Will Tulane most likely get bta? Yeah sure. But they had a hell of a season and deserve ts
4
Anonymous1w
What I don’t understand is why they put Tulane against Ole Miss when Ole Miss already kicked their ass…should’ve swapped Tulane and JMU
1
Anonymous1w
We arnt omitting shit if you want to be in the playoff you should be a top twelve team
-1
AnonymousOP1w
The playoffs weren’t built to have the most talented teams. It was built to have the most deserving teams. If it was by talent we’d have the same teams year in and year out and that’s BORING
6
Anonymous#11w
Yup. I’m in favor of NIL but if it’s going to make CFB a minor league then HELL NO. If the SEC wants to be high and mighty go do it somewhere else. Don’t ruin ts for me and other fans
5
Anonymous#21w
Tulane is a top 12 team. They are conference champs, went 11-2, and have a very talented staff
5
AnonymousOP1w
Texas/ Vandy notre dame Utah all have significantly better resumes shut up
0
Anonymous#21w
Any of them conference champions?
1
AnonymousOP1w
Best win over who north fucking Texas Tulane got obliterated by fucking utsa !!!shut up
-1
Anonymous#21w
Maybe Texas/Vandy/ND/BYU should’ve won their games/conference. Not Tulane’s fault in the slightest those teams messed up
2
Anonymous#11w
Ok all those teams are significantly better than Tulane what are you talking about
2
Anonymous#21w
Doesn’t matter that’s not the criteria to get in
2
Anonymous#11w
That not what me and ole miss are arguing about can you fucking read
0
Anonymous#21w
Me and op
0
Anonymous#21w
Being a top 12 isn’t the entire criteria to get in. That isn’t the criteria because there is no objectively correct way to actually judge that with only 12 teams out of 136
6
Anonymous#11w
Op is trying to tell me they are a top 12 team I am arguing they are not you fundamentally do not understand my argument stop typing
0
Anonymous#21w
This is how ik you don’t know ball. UNT lost to a scrappy UTSA team who had the second longest home streak at that time. Tulane has been amazing all year with the exception of ole miss
7
Anonymous#21w
It seems they mean in terms of final CFP rankings. Objectively they aren’t, but I’m guessing your argument is that it SHOULD be the top 12 regardless of anything else. Maybe use context clues when reading?
3
AnonymousOP1w
Cook him op
1
Anonymous#11w
Incorrect they were rank 17 in the final cfp rankings
0
AnonymousOP1w
They also beat Duke, ACC champs, Memphis, who was almost the g5 rep, and UNT, another almost g5 rep who had a top 5 qb this year
1
Anonymous#21w
Yeah because the rankings are ALWAYS correct
1
AnonymousOP1w
They also got blown out by utsa
0
Anonymous#21w
It doesn’t really matter because of the AQ though
3
Anonymous#21w
Again. They had the second longest home streak at 25. It’s hard to beat UTSA at home. The UTSA qb is underrated. You do not know ball and it’s okay but you should pipe down
5
Anonymous#11w
1
AnonymousOP1w
😭
0
Anonymous#21w
Again- you are basing this on the rankings. The rankings are not the end all be all. If you legitimately think that they are: YOU ARE DUMB
4
AnonymousOP1w
I’m basing this on the fact that Tulane does not have as good a resume as Vandy Texas Utah byu or Notre dame
0
Anonymous#21w
Tulane has a better resume than all those teams. Tulane has a better record than everyone except BYU (their records are identical). Tulane is the only conference game out of the teams you mentioned. They won the automatic qualifier. The other teams did not. Simple as that
1
AnonymousOP1w
0
Anonymous#21w
How many times do I have to say it- the record is not the end all be all. Are you illiterate?
1
Anonymous#21w
I legit think you just hate the magic of college football bro. If you want to watch elite players play at the highest level go watch the nfl. Ts is supposed to be FUN. The same teams from the same conference is boring and destroys the meaning of regular season conference play
1
AnonymousOP1w
😭 you haven’t said that at all in fact you are the one who keeps bringing up records
0
Anonymous#21w
Bro what? All you’ve done is bring up rankings and resumes
1
AnonymousOP1w
0
Anonymous#21w
If this is rage bait it’s damn good cause it got me
0
Anonymous#31w
If the committee wants them in? Fine just don’t make them replay a game where they already got their asses kicked
1
Anonymous#31w
I would’ve preferred that as well but my assumption was the automatic qualifier was the reason for the rematch
3
AnonymousOP1w
Yeah but like both teams were auto qualifiers so putting one team against a team they got destroyed by is just the committee trying to embarrass them for what 😭
1
Anonymous#11w
I feel like people forget cfb was intended for amateur or recreational play, not to be a feeder system for the NFL.