
Well what the committee DOES and what they are SUPPOSED to do clearly don’t align. Yes, they heavily critique losses more so than they reward wins. Doesn’t mean they are supposed to. Your rank is supposed to be a combination of your wins, losses, SOS, and SOR. Based off what it is supposed to be? Texas Tech should be above Wake Forest. A wake forest with 1 loss, 1 ranked win, a top 10 SOR, and roughly 75 SOS should not be above a Texas Tech with 1 loss, 3 ranked wins, a top 10 SOR and a 55 SOS.
Sure, Miami is definitely a better loss than Cincinnati, but I think 3 ranked wins outweighs that. I also would like to mention that one ranked wins Wake forest has? Louisville. Who at that time was not ranked, stayed unranked, and has just now scraped into the top 25. Barely. So truthfully saying they have 1 ranked win is being generous in itself as TECHNICALLY Louisville wasn’t ranked at that time.
If they are consistent then why is BYU below ND? Sure, BYU has 2 losses but one of those is to the current #2 and they are very clearly okay with putting 2 loss teams above 1 loss teams. However that shouldn’t matter since BYU has the head to head over ND? So with your logic, who cares if one of those losses is UCF. I guess that just means UCF should be above BYU and ND? Its consistentttt.