
The article isn’t about rare or antique books. It’s about used books published before 2022, many of which are unlikely to sell. The bookseller interviewed even says many would otherwise end up recycled. This isn’t a conspiracy to destroy valuable knowledge. Many books simply have little demand, and libraries and used bookstores regularly recycle unsold books
This is just… weird. I could only access the first article OP provided so maybe I’m missing something. The fact that they’re destroying the books to scan them is bizarre given there are perfectly safe ways to scan books??? Also the fact that a digital copy of a book is considered a “single” copy and therefore “replacing” the original copy and therefore legal, is crazy to me considering they would’ve bought a COPY of the book and not the RIGHTS to the content…
…which they are clearly using to train AI. #6 has a point, and also not. The thing I don’t get, and maybe this is the info I am missing. I don’t see anything indicating that these books are rare, and I also don’t see anything indicating these books are so old and degraded that they’re about to be recycled anyway. I only see that they’re pre-2022, pre- chat gpt. Again, I could only read the yahoo article which itself looked ai generated to me, so like. Yeah 😅
It is being overall dramatically I search multiple article and they not destroying rare books in the sense thst it was an 1700 limited edition book but they are trying to scan more unknown books so books written by your mom that noone bought and sold 10 copies. So it is rare in the sense that it might be the only copy but only because noone is buying it. The reason why they destory and only making one copy because they don't own the right to the book so they just making sure they can't be sued
Rare and antique books are not usually discarded because of relatively minor flaws. I work in a special collections & archives, the VAST majority of our collection is books in some degree of disrepair because that is simply a symptom of antiquity, and when we get duplicate copies we don’t need they are sent to others who need them. Most libraries understand the significance of irreplaceable items